HomeMy WebLinkAbout06 Ontario Public School Boards' Association Chairs' ReportLIZ SANDALS
President
All I
Q p 8 s a
GAIL ANDERSON
Executive Director
ONTARIO PUBLIC SCHOOL BOARDS, ASSOCIATION
439 UNIVERSITY AVENUE, 18th FLOOR, TORONTO, ONTARIO M5G 1Y8
TELEPHONE: (416) 340 -2540 ! FAX: (416) 340 -7571
WEBSITE: www.opsba.org
Liz Sandals= Speaking Notes
Queen =s Park Media Studio
Wednesday, January 30, 2002
When the provincial funding formulafor educationwas introduced in 1998, its stated goal
was to address inequities in the public education system and make funding fair across
the province. Under this new model, the government dictates how much each board can
spend and to a large extent, what the money must be used for. By seizing complete
control of education funding, the provincial government has assumed absolute
responsibility for ensuring adequate funding of education.
Boards around the province reportthat the biggest problem with the funding model is that
it's quite simply out -of -date B half a decade out -of -date to be exact. The government has
addressed system -wide equity by funding all boards inadequately. All the funding
benchmarks in the funding formula are based on 1997 costs (implying that the >97
costing was an acceptable standard even then). Apparently the provincial government
hasn =t noticed it is now 2002 and that the funding benchmarks must be adjusted to
cover current costs.
Let's examine the impact of underfunding on the classroom. Since 1998 the pupil -
teacher ratio in elementary schools has increased. There has been a reduction in
student resources in both elementary and secondary classrooms as evidenced in
textbook and learning materials shortages and the reliance on outdated technology. The
range of programs and services offered to students such as library and guidance and
specialty teachers in music and physical education, has been reduced. So has school -
based and board staff for studentsupport. And the waiting lists for student assessments
for special needs and the time before initiating intervention have increased. Boards are
increasingly subject to legal challenges over lack of special education services.
There has also been limited professional development to ensure that teachers can
deliver the complex and demanding new curriculum. In addition, a serious international
teacher shortage has created a competitive environment fortheir services and is forcing
salaries upward. Our taxes are being used to train new teachers who are subsequently
1
to, I
coaxed to the United States with a range of incentives and a welcoming atmosphere.
So how big is the problem? The Ontario Public School Boards= Association in
partnership with the school boards= senior business officials and Directors of education
have attempted to quantify the current funding gap. We have used data which is in a
consistent format B that is, the format in which we are required to report to the Ministry of
Education. We have examined the budget estimates, revised budget estimates and
financial statements of boards in all 4 publicly- funded systems. The data analysis has
been conducted by professional accountants who are also certified school business
officials (not by politicians).
With the exception of the proposed transportation model, let =s assume that the structure
of the funding formula is appropriate. If we compare the actual costs of running the
system versus the theoretical costs on which the funding benchmarks are based, school
boards are facing a conservative $1.1 B gap. Let me repeat that figure -- $1.1 B short of
adequate funding for schools.
The break down is estimated as follows:
$ salaries and benefits $589M
$ technology $200M
$ textbooks and learning material $50M
$ transportation $57M
$ Special education $84M
$ professional development $71 M
Salaries and benefits
Not surprisingly, in a school system the greatest pressure is in teacher salaries and
benefits. We have analysed the current actual costs of teacher salaries and benefits and
plugged the actual costs into the provincial funding model. Salaries are underfunded by
$456 M and benefits by $133 M for a total of $589 M.
Technology
The provincial funding for technology is based on 1997 expenditure levels that amount
to $43 for each elementary student and $56 for each secondary student. The funding
includes only classroom computers, peripherals and software but excludes technical
training, technical support, or internet access costs. In other words, your child =s
classroom may have computers, but it may be impossible to get an internet connection
with an acceptable response time and if the computers malfunction B tough!
The level of funding for technology is woefully inadequate for a province that should be
on the leading edge of using classroom technology to improve student learning. The
provincial funding for technology does not reflect mandated school board information
management systems nor the increased provincial electronic reporting requirements for
which all boards are accountable. In order to keep equipment up -to -date and provide
2
adequate service we need an extra $200M.
Textbooks and Learning materials
In 2002, funding fortextbooks and learning materials is based on 1997 levels. The issue
is exacerbated when funding for new textbooks and learning materials required to
implement the curriculum reform was arbitrarily reduced by 50% or $15M in 2001/02 The
funding gap has resulted in reductions in texts and learning materials thus creating a
greater dependence and pressure on local fund raising efforts for core classroom
materials.
Transportation
Transportation is another area of chronic underfunding. While the funding "top -ups"
received by boards the last two years are appreciated, they do not bring us any closer to
a workable transportation funding model. The initial budget estimates for 2001/02
showed 62 of 72 boards with a total transportation deficit of $57.3 M. Grants need to be
increased to address 2002 fuel costs and aging bus fleets. $57 Malso does not address
the need to improve service for students who are currently walking up to 4.8 km morning
and afternoon. Cabinet approval of the funding to support the proposed new and realistic
transportation model is long overdue.
Special Education
The funding of special education has been a continuing challenge for public boards.
School boards have diverted $84M from other program areas to address under funding
in special education. Our special education coordinators around the province report that
the number of very high needs children in our schools is increasing. As a consequence,
special education programs for low to moderate needs children continue to be cut -
something akin to emergency room triage for special needs children. School boards
have also been forced to make significant reductions in speech pathologists,
psychologists, and psychiatrists because the funding is inadequate. $84 M would only
address current spending on special education B it would not address programs and
services which have already been cut.
Professional Development
Professional development has the most direct effect on program quality and full
implementation of new program initiatives. Since 1997 the province has implemented
major changes to elementary and secondary curriculum. In addition, new demands have
been placed on boards such as safe schools initiatives, and performance appraisals of
teachers with very little financial support from the province. Adequate professional
development would cost an additional $70.5 M.
Other
We have not even tried at this point to quantify the funding gap due to a 28% rise in utility
costs, or due to out -of -date benchmarks for support staff salaries and benefits. $1.1 B
is a conservative estimate.
3
9
4.
Implications for 2002/03 Grants
The cost pressures on school boards have obviouslybeen recognized but not funded by
the provincial government. Education Minister Janet Ecker outlined the problems at a
meeting of the Conservative caucus in August 2001. She highlighted a $6.8 B backlog
in deferred maintenance on school buildings, with some schools in such rough shape
that they need to be demolished and rebuilt. Provincial grants for school renewal currently
amount to about $240 M per year. According to the Ministry=s own analysis, if we wish to
keep our school buildings in decent repair, we need to add $1 B per year to provincial
funding.
Minister Ecker explained to her colleagues that 16 school boards had already exhausted
their reserves in order to balance their budgets. In fact, for English Public Boards, total
working reserves have declined by 39% from $112 M in 1997 (before takeover) to $68.5
M in 2000/01. The downward spiral continues this year.
So what is the current financial reality in Ontario School Boards? For English Public
Boards, in 1998, the first -year of the funding model, 12 had operating surpluses totalling
$12.6 M. Only 3 had deficits. By the end of 2000/01, 11 boards were in deficit for a total
of $35.4M. Only 2 had surpluses. We estimate that about 50% of boards will be in deficit
at the end of 2001 -02.
Bankrupt
Let me be clear, the school boards in this province are bankrupt or very close to being
bankrupt. Our only source of revenue is the provincial government and with the money we
are getting this year and expect to get next year, we will not have sufficient funding to meet
our contractual or legal obligations.
School boards are legally responsible for developing a balanced budget, within the
funding provided by the ministry. However, boards are also charged with the legal
responsibility of conforming to: classsize and workload requirements in the Education
Act, Special Education legislation, the Labour Relations Act, the Occupational Health and
Safety Act, and the Pay Equity Act to name but a few. School boards= question to the
provincial government is rapidly becoming, AWhich law would you like us to break ?@
It is becoming increasingly clear that minor tinkering with the school board funding model
won't solve the problems. As I have previously stated, the Ontario Public School Boards=
Association calculates that the gap between school board revenues and legitimate
expenditure pressures exceeds $1.1 billion annually. Any cut, freeze or even minimal
increase in per pupil revenue is unworkable. If the provincial government fails to provide
a significant cash infusion for public education, public district school boards will clearly
be faced with a choice between gutting student programs or running a deficit.
4
Running a deficit is against the law. Funding education at 1997 costs is impossible.
1997 dollars won =t buy 2002 goods, services or student programs. .
I truly believe that Ontario has one of the best education systems in the world. Platitudes
from the government about managing the provincial economy to ensure the future well-
being of our children aren't good enough. Our children are currently being educated in
significantly underfunded schools. If funding a strong public education system is the
most important investment we can make as a society, then the financial commitment
must be made today because for our children, the future begins now.
5