HomeMy WebLinkAbout04 Special Purpose Budget Report 2, 3 Oct 2000-9
OTTAWA - CARLETON DISTRICT SCHOOL BOARD
REPORT NO. 2
SPECIAL PURPOSE BUDGET COMMITTEE
TO: Board of Education DATE: 3 October 2000
A meeting of the Special Purpose Budget Committee was held this evening at 133 Greenbank Road,
commencing at 7:45 p.m. with Trustee Pam Morse in the Chair, and the following in attendance: Trustees Alex
Getty, Lynn Graham, Patty Anne Hill, Jim Libbey, Norm MacDonald (by phone), Sheryl MacDonald, and Lynn
Scott.
Staff. Director of Education and Secretary of the Board, James Grieve; Superintendents Michael Clarke,
and Judy Turriff, Manager /Comptroller of Finance, Marie- Louise Chartrand; Coordinator of Budget Services and
Financial Systems Support, Charles D'Aoust; Manager of Communications, Maggie Melenhorst; Management,
Policy and Planning Advisor, Janice Sargent; A/V Technician Robert Giekes and Committee Coordinator, Bruce
Fraser.
Non - Voting Representatives: Ottawa - Carleton Elementary Principals' Association, Donald Cram; Ottawa
Carleton Secondary School Administrators' Network, Diana Thomas; Ottawa Carleton Elementary Teachers'
Federation, Bonnie Robinson; OSSTF Teachers, Tony Pearson, OSSTF/Education Support Professionals, Lorraine
Smith, Ottawa- Carleton Assembly of School Councils, Cynthia Pohran; Special Education Advisory Committee,
Casey van der Grient.
Approval of Agenda
On a motion by Trustee Graham, the agenda was approved as presented.
2. Review of Directorate
Superintendent Clarke remarked that staff would review the Directorate and the Financial Services areas
and that School Operations would be discussed at a future meeting. He noted that Financial Services staff are
currently developing a spreadsheet which will provide details of the entire budget on a single page.
Using slides to present an overview of the Directorate, Director Grieve outlined the responsibilities of each
of the following areas:
• Director's Office
• Superintendents
• Board Services
• Legal Advisor
• Management, Policy and Planning Advisor
• Communications
• Trustees
He reviewed the financial resources, including salaries and benefits that are allocated to each of the areas as
one of nine potential funding sources, and demonstrated their relationship to the operating costs.
The Director noted that System Professional Member Fees, listed under the Director's area, are used to
cover professional membership fees for all staff required to maintain membership in organizations as a condition of
their professional designation. Program Development funds, also from the Director's area, are used to offset the
costs associated with emerging initiatives, as well as special events and conference organization, that warrant
financial support but have not been budgeted for directly.
Special Purpose Budget Committee - 1 - 3 October 2000
'7•
Questions/Discussion
In response to a query by Tony Pearson, Chair Morse advised that staff will provide answers where
possible, but questions may be submitted in writing for a staff response. Director Grieve noted that these evenings
are to provide information in an informal setting. The purpose of the meetings is to provide stakeholders with a
level of detail that will help to clarify the process and assist in the development of the next budget.
Staff clarified that the contingency funds in the Director's area are charged against the Instruction Funding
Source, as it is funding that is directed to support school initiatives and therefore is considered as a cost against
instruction.
In response to a query, staff advised that while changes to the full time equivalent figures are noted in the
back up material, some adjustments to costs could have resulted from the transfer of responsibilities from another
area.
Superintendent Clarke agreed to provide the change for each department, by category, as an addendum to
the financial breakdown for each area. He noted that the information can be provided in electronic form. He
remarked that the information sheets strike a balance between the amount of information provided and the clarity of
the document.
Trustee Norm MacDonald noted that the actual operating costs for 1999/2000 appear to be 33% lower than
projected and asked why the 2000/2001 budget reflects an increase of approximately 33% over the actual figures.
Staff advised that the information will be reviewed as part of the next budget process and that costs in some areas
are still reflective of the merger between the two former boards. Superintendent Clarke noted that all operational
variances roll into reserves at year -end and the reserves have been used to maintain existing programs.
Superintendent Clarke advised that the salary and benefits budget information for the Communications
Department was based on original assumptions, but the $297,000 figure was insufficient to cover the department's
eight F.T.E. positions. The figure was adjusted in the 2000/2001 budget projection. He remarked that this was an
example of the transfer of positions from another area, noting that responsibility for the switchboard was transferred
from Board Services.
Director Grieve, in response to a query by Trustee Scott, cited system wide planning initiatives such as the
Futures program, consultants' fees, travel expenses for the Director or members of the Ottawa - Carleton Assembly
of School Councils attending meetings with representatives of the Ministry of Education, public speaking contests
and assistance with student transfer appeals as examples of initiatives which would be funded with the Director's
Program Development budget. Trustee Scott commented that the separation of operating costs from Program
Development initiatives would be appreciated as trustees could reduce funds without realizing what is actually being
affected. Staff agreed to clarify this area as much as possible.
During discussion trustees and observers requested clarification or information in a number of areas. The
following items were noted:
• figures for overtime and temporary assistance, for areas with large amounts in either category, will be
listed separately
• the percentage split for Funding Source "4) Central Administration/Instruction" will be identified;
• a grand summary for Salary & Benefits showing `old" and "new" figures will be included;
• the total of discretionary versus necessary advertising costs will be calculated;
• organizational charts for each area will be provided;
• the description of Board Services will be expanded to better reflect the department's mandate;
• more details of the Ottawa - Carleton Assembly of School Councils' budget will be provided.
In response to a query, Superintendent Clarke explained that it would be difficult to isolate costs related to
individual programs, such as Special Education, as there is no consensus on how to allocate common costs to them.
Special Purpose Budget Committee - 2 - 3 October 2000
_DV .
Several trustees and observers requested that staff provide information which cross - references the different
provincial funding envelopes with actual budget expenditures.
Trustee Getty urged trustees to be aware of the big picture and to refrain from attempting to micro manage
the budget. He commented that the level of detail provided in the back -up was adequate overall, but requested that
additional narrative and supporting information be provided, for large ticket items, in order to reduce the number of
questions.
Review of the Financial Services Department
Superintendent Clarke provided an overview of the Financial Services Department and outlined the
responsibilities and workload of the Department as well as the financial resources allocated to each of the following
areas:
• Superintendent of Finance
• Admissions and Enrolment
• Budget Development and Financial Systems Support
• Financial Reporting
• Payroll
• Purchasing/Materiel Management
He noted that the salaries and benefits area for the Superintendent of Finance was included under the
Superintendents area of the Review of the Directorate.
Ouestions/Discussion
During discussion, staff addressed a number of queries and the following points were noted:
• Four student information systems are required due to the delay in delivery of the Trillium system
which was to be used to amalgamate the systems (elementary and secondary) from each of the former
boards.
• The Purchasing Department overtime budget was based on historical data from both former boards;
• The costs for application software and license fees are for Quicken and upgrades to the SRB reporting
system;
• Costs associated with activities or services for schools (furniture and equipment transfers, application
software) would be included under the Instruction funding source.
• Salaries/benefit cost increases are due to the harmonization of salaries and benefits as well as
contractual obligations.
• Approximately 70 - 75 percent of the Finance Department staff is unionized.
• Staffing was reduced by approximately 20 positions from the pre - amalgamation levels.
• The annual report of the Four Board Purchasing Consortium will be provided.
The meeting adjourned at 10:20 p.m.
Pam Morse
Chair
Committee of the Whole (Budget)
bf/031000
Special Purpose Budget Committee - 3 - 3 October 2000