HomeMy WebLinkAbout03.17 Delegation Owen Mahaffy re RECAPP ResultsRECAPP FACILITY RENEWAL AUDIT CRITIQUE
Presented to: the Trustees of the Ottawa Carleton District School Board
By: Owen Mahaffy, P.Eng.
September 28, 2000
Summary
,�1.
1. The purpose of this presentation is to demonstrate that while the RECAPP
audit process is a valid means of determining capital expenditure priority
planning across a large portfolio of assets, it is not an effective tool for
quantifying definitive costs and timing of investments in the near -term.
2. An analysis of the prioritized items identified in an example RECAPP audit
(Elmdale Public School) will show that a reduction in the estimated 10 year
renewal costs of over 80% is possible while still improving the overall
condition of the facility. See graph.
3. RECAPP is extremely precise, in terms of cost and timing, in dealing with
events that are, by their nature, highly unpredictable; thus the margin for error
is high.
4. The long -term operating costs of facilities are of more importance in making
efficient use of all assets. Operating costs are real, not predicted, and are
equal to or greater than the total RECAPP renewal costs over the same
period. In order for a facility assessment to be valid, these costs must also
be factored into the final decision. Neither RECAPP nor the Board staff
analysis has done this.
5. RECAPP renewal costs and operating costs should not be compared based
on $ /pupil place because:
- The MOE capacity figures are unrealistic and misleading.
- It permits no measure of actual efficiency based on real occupancy.
6. The scrutiny of the RECAPP process, when focussed on a small number of
facilities (the nine schools recommended for closure), distorts the real
condition of those facilities relative to the average. The average RECAPP
renewal costs for the nine schools recommended for closure is less
than 9% higher than the average for all OCDSB elementary schools.
7. RECAPP is an all- inclusive "wish list ". The reality is, many items are never
addressed or alternative, lower cost, incremental fixes are the only option.
$2,800,000
$2,400,000
$2,000,000
v $1,600,000
m
eo
E $1,200,000
V
$800,000
Elmdale Public School
Cumulative Event Costs vs. Cumulative Base Funding
■ RECAPP Cumulative Cost ❑ Revised Cumulative Cost
❑ Base Funding Level
$2,414,984