HomeMy WebLinkAbout09e Delegation Joan Spice re Criteria for School Closure Processr
OTTAWA - CARLETON ASSEMBLY OF SCHOOL COUNCILS
DELEGATION TO THE BOARD
DATE: Wednesday, May 24, 2000
TOPIC: OCASC Motion on School Closure Criteria
Presenters: Betty Tait — OCASC Vice - Chair, Joan Spice — OCASC School Closure Committee Member
At its general meeting held on Thursday, 18 May 2000, Assembly members overwhelmingly passed a
motion concerning recommendations for criteria with regard to the current OCDSB school closure process.
OCASC motion 00 -05 -01 reads as follows:
Whereas the OCDSB is currently in the process of considering school closures;
BE IT THEREFORE RESOLVED THAT OCASC RECOMMEND TO THE BOARD THAT:
1. There should be more than one set of closure options for each family of schools;
2. There should be a detailed situational analysis for each recommended closure option with factors
affecting quality of education, equality of access, and health and safety being the most important criteria;
3. Revised "made in Ottawa - Carleton" capacity for all affected schools be provided as part of the closure
recommendations to take into account at least special education reallocations since last year;
4. Given the potential for using portables inside the Greenbelt is in many cases constrained by lack of
outdoor space, the revised capacity information include the number of portables that could reasonably be
located on each school's property;
5. The Board (that is the Trustees) determine a portable allocation policy prior to reallocating portables for
2000 -2001 and that the policy include the following guidelines designed to ensure that the quality of
education not be adversely affected by the removal of portables:
a) that principals be invited to submit written recommendations related to portable allocation at their
schools and that their recommendations be explicitly taken into account in the reallocation;
b) that portables not be removed if it would result in excessive noise, crowding or air quality concerns
due to open concept classrooms or that these difficulties be alleviated by erecting barriers or in other
ways before portables are removed;
c) that the number of kindergarten classes be taken into account and portables not be removed if an
uneven number of kindergarten classes would mean overcrowding in the school; and
d) that portables not be removed if such removals would require closure of computer labs; and that
consideration be given to allocating portables if schools wish to add computer labs.
6. The Board take into account in its closure options that, generally, operating close to, at or over 100% is
likely to be more acceptable for small schools than for large schools;
7. In areas where the community is now served by two or more schools and where quality of education and
cost factors are similar, other factors (e.g. community impact) will assume larger importance as
determining closure factors;
8. The Board demonstrates improvements to its enrolment projection methodology for the planning period.
Our delegation on Wednesday, May 24 will speak further to the points raised within the OCASC motion
and answer any questions you may have concerning the rationale behind the motion.
(TEXT OF OCASC MOTION 00 -05 -01 SUBJECT TO APPROVAL OF ASSEMBLY MINUTES)