HomeMy WebLinkAbout14 Education Report 4, 15 May 20006i.
OTTAWA - CARLETON DISTRICT SCHOOL BOARD
REPORT NO. 4, EDUCATION COMMITTEE
TO: Board of Education DATE: 15 May 2000
A meeting of the Education Committee was held this evening in the Trustees' Committee Room,
133 Greenbank Road, Nepean, commencing at 7:00 p.m. with Trustee Patty Anne Hill in the Chair, and the
following in attendance:
MEMBERS: Trustees Jun Libbey and Lynn Scott
Also present: Trustee Sheryl MacDonald.
STAFF: Superintendent of Program, Quality Assurance & Staff Development, Dan
Mason; Superintendents of Schools, Judith Hoye and Judy Turriff; Research
Associate, Linda Clarke; Manager, Quality Assurance, Marjorie Clegg;
Principal, Staff Development, Margaret Dempsey; Principal, Special Education,
Laura McAlister; Principal, Program, Bob Powell; Committee Coordinator, Kim
Young.
NON - VOTING
REPRESENTATIVES: Lisa Falls, OCETF; Bill Hollingsworth, OCSSAN; Myrna Laurenceson, SEAC;
Tony Pearson, OSSTF; and Betty Tait, OCASC.
ALSO PRESENT: Presenters Sharon Fotheringham and Patricia Marek - Thornton, Speech and
Language Pathologists.
(W Please Note: Throughout the meeting, Trustee Libbey assumed the Chair when Trustee Hill wished to
participate in the discussion.
1. Approval of the Agenda
On a motion by Trustee Sheryl MacDonald, the agenda was approved, subject to moving item No.
12, Primary Language Literacy Project Presentation, to follow item No. 3, Public Question
Period.
Public Question Period
There were no questions from the public.
Primary Language Literacy Project Presentation
Superintendent Hoye introduced Patricia Marek - Thornton and Sharon Fotheringham, OCDSB
Speech and Language Pathologists, who presented a brief overview of the 10 May 2000 launch of the First
Words project, funded by a Learning Opportunities Grant (LOG) from the Ministry, and supported by
several OCDSB departments and community agencies. Ms. Marek - Thornton and Ms. Fotheringham
emphasized the importance of encouraging parents to speak with their children in their first language, as
this activity contributes greatly to the child's success in mastering a second language. They pointed out that
a growing population of at risk families and children reside in the Ottawa - Carleton region and that First
Words is responding to the need this population has for intensified language leaming help.
Ms. Marek- Thornton and Ms. Fotheringham provided staff and trustees with First Words posters
and brochures, which are available to the public in five languages: English, French, Somali, Arabic and
Mandarin. Every effort was made to ensure that the professionally illustrated poster and five language
Education Committee -1- 15 May 2000
colour -coded brochures were clearly written, sensitive to multicultural factors, cost - efficient and easily
duplicated for the widest distribution possible.
In response to Trustee Sheryl MacDonald's query, the presenters explained that since the project is
a joint venture between First Words, the Ottawa - Carleton Preschool Program (funded by the Ministry of
Health) and the OCDSB, any decisions about the distribution or sale of the resource materials must be a
joint one. It has been the project coordinators' intention to develop the resources for Ottawa - Carleton area
families in need, and to those working with this at risk population. The possibility of selling the materials
must be further explored with administrators of both agencies involved. They noted that the priorities in
designing and implementing the project were to keep costs minimal and to make the information available
to as many stakeholders as possible.
Lisa Falls commended the speech language pathologists for their efforts and encouraged them to
contact the OCETF about making a presentation to the federation. Ms. Falls felt that the elementary
teachers' federation would find the information very useful.
4. Receipt of Special Education Advisory Committee Report, 3 May 2000
On a motion by Trustee Scott, the Committee received Report No. 8 from the Special Education
Advisory Committee, dated 3 May 2000.
There were no recommendations in the report.
Trustee Scott requested that the motion on Page 4, No. 7 of the report be amended as follows:
THAT SEAC delegate responsibility to a sub -group of representatives to produce a parallel submission to
the Ministry under SEAC cover, by 15 May 2000. The paragraph following the motion will also be revised
to reflect the intent of her friendly amendment.
Myrna Laurenceson requested that 'disabled in the fifth point under Parents /Guardians on page 5
of the report be replaced with 'disability'.
Myrna Laurenceson asked that the following sentence be inserted in the third paragraph, page 7 of
the report, following "regarding special education needs. ": Trustee Scott advised that in the former CBE,
there existed a seldom used practice of allowing a SEAC representative to contribute to trustee debate at
board meetings, if major SEAC motions were under discussion.
In response to Myrna Laurenceson's query as to whether the Board has written to the Ministry
about the congregated gifted program, Superintendent Mason noted that a letter is being prepared.
On a motion by Trustee Scott, your Committee recommends:
THAT REPORT NO. 8 FROM THE SPECIAL EDUCATION ADVISORY COMMITTEE,
DATED 3 MAY 2000, BE RECEIVED. (ATTACHED AS APPENDIX A)
5. Music Information Nights
Your Committee had before it staff report No. 00 -121 providing information about music
information nights and seeking approval for the distribution of a letter to all schools, containing a
comprehensive list of vendors/suppliers who rent or sell musical instruments. The report also seeks
approval for the Program Division to explore, with the Purchasing department, the possibility of developing
a "pre - qualified list" of suppliers /vendors for the 2000 -2001 school year. A letter to all principals of
intermediate schools regarding music information nights was distributed at the meeting.
Principal Powell provided a brief overview of the report noting that a committee of principals was
established to review the method that schools used to provide parents with information about purchasing or
renting a musical instrument. Schools use a variety of methods to inform parents, including music
Education Committee -2- 15 May 2000
6 o5 .
information nights, and the distribution to parents of lists of suppliers /vendors who sell or rent instruments.
He noted that an extensive list has been prepared for this year and that staff worked closely with Grade 7
and 8 teachers in creating the list.
Trustees who supported the recommendation expressed their pleasure that the issue is being
addressed in a transparent and timely manner. They noted the importance of ensuring that the list of
vendors/suppliers is complete.
Superintendent Mason noted that the Program Division would work closely with the Purchasing
Department to ensure that all possible vendors /suppliers will be included on the list.
Trustee Scott moved the recommendation in the staff report.
The motion was carried. On a motion by Trustee Scott, your Committee therefore recommends:
A. THAT FOR THIS YEAR, A LETTER CONTAINING A COMPREHENSIVE LIST OF
SUPPLIERSNENDORS WHO SELL OR RENT MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS, BE
PREPARED AND ISSUED BY THE PROGRAM DIVISION IN COOPERATION
WITH THE PURCHASING DEPARTMENT, TO ALL SCHOOLS.
B. THAT THE PROGRAM DIVISION EXPLORE WITH THE PURCHASING
DEPARTMENT, THE POSSIBILITY OF DEVELOPING A "PRE- QUALIFIED LIST"
OF SUPPLIERSNENDORS FOR THE SCHOOL YEAR 2000 -2001.
6. Special Education Comprehensive Plan Report
Your Committee had before it for consideration staff report No. 00 -104 seeking approval for the
(W report to the Ministry of Education regarding the May 1999 Special Education Comprehensive Plan. The
letter from the Ministry requesting that the OCDSB address specific SEAC - related concerns and the
OCDSB's subsequent report forms part of the staff report.
Principal McAlister reviewed the report, noting that all school boards must report to the Ministry
each year by May 15 regarding changes to their Comprehensive Plans. This year, while there have been no
changes to the OCDSB's Plan, the school board has been asked to provide a response to SEAC and to the
Ministry regarding SEAC's involvement in developing special education programs and services in 2000.
She drew the members' attention to the inclusion of references in the report to the Special Education
Student Services Program Review and the motion regarding waiting lists for assessment, as requested by
SEAC.
Principal McAlister explained that the impact of the budget - related changes to special education
does not warrant a full report to the Ministry this year. The Ministry is concerned with global changes to
the Comprehensive Plan. She noted that the OCDSB is in compliance with Ministry guidelines.
In response to a query, Principal McAlister advised that the OCDSB is not involved in the
Ministry's efforts to establish new special education standards. The school board has repeatedly mentioned
to the Ministry its interest in participating in the standards process.
In response to Trustee Libbey's query about the involvement of other school boards in the
establishment of province -wide standards and an estimate as to when the board might receive the new
standards, staff agreed to investigate the status of these issues.
Myrna Laurenceson noted that SEAC is currently drafting a letter to the Ministry regarding the
move towards greater accountability and province -wide standards for special education service delivery, as
announced in a 27 January 2000 Ministry news release.
Trustee Libbey moved the recommendation in the staff report.
Education Committee -3- 15 May 2000
�q-
Trustee Scott requested that the report be revised to clarify that the Special Education Delivery
Model is being reviewed on an ongoing basis and that SEAC will have continued involvement in this
process. She also asked that the report include a statement that while the OCDSB has reduced the number
of special education classes, this does not mean that students do not have access to specialized programs.
Several trustees requested that the report include a list identifying those motions that were adopted
for implementation in 2000 -2001, e.g., waiting list for assessment, and those that require further
investigation prior to implementation, e.g., Centres of Excellence.
The motion was carried. On a motion by Trustee Libbey, your Committee therefore recommends:
THAT THE SPECIAL EDUCATION COMPREHENSIVE PLAN REPORT TO THE
MINISTRY OF EDUCATION BE APPROVED. (ATTACHED AS APPENDIX B)
Note: The suggestions made during the discussion are reflected in Appendix B.
7. Facts and Figures re: 1999 -2000 Worknlans
Your Committee had before it for information staff report No. 00 -127 providing an update on the
status of the 1999 -2000 workplans from the Program, Staff Development and Quality Assurance divisions.
Superintendent Mason noted that in the fall of 1998 the three newly formed divisions presented
trustees with its first set of workplans which were designed to direct the departments' work and inform
trustees and stakeholders about the nature of and processes associated with the various tasks. In May 1999,
the division heads presented an update on the plans to the Education Committee, and at the June meeting, a
workplan for the following year. He explained that staff will present an overview of its recent activities as
a prelude to the presentation of workplans for 2000 -2001 at the June Education Committee meeting.
Division leaders Margorie Clegg, Margaret Dempsey and Robert Powell used overhead
presentations to bring trustees up to date on the implementation of the 1999 -2000 action plans.
Superintendent Mason noted that trustees will receive a copy of the overheads in their Friday package.
During the discussion following the presentations, members and staff raised a number of points:
• The $1 million allocated in the budget for secondary school reform has been very useful to the
Program division in its efforts to prepare schools for the changes to the secondary level
curriculum.
• Secondary school reform inservice for teachers is being held both during school hours and
after school. Every effort is being made to reach as many teachers as possible. Trustee
Sheryl MacDonald expressed concern that with the new Ministry regulations about secondary
instructional time and co- instructional activities, teachers will have less time available to
participate in after school workshops.
The OCDSB received $99,000 from the Ministry to be used between 20 March and 31
December 2000 in training teachers about the upcoming curriculum changes. Nine
elementary school teacher release days have been allocated for inservice, as well as seven
days for secondary school teachers. Principal Powell noted that the OCDSB has been using
the available days and will continue to do so in the fall of 2000. He also noted that the
OCDSB has used the Ministry funded days to supplement its own training workshops.
• Information about the development of an index for identifying high needs schools will be
available at the June Education Committee meeting.
Education Committee -4- 15 May 2000
66.
• The OCDSB is partnered with the Ontario Institute for Studies in Education/University of
Toronto in developing tests for French. Staff noted that there is potential for marketing the
materials for profit.
During a brief discussion of the impact of the Ministry's curriculum changes on Grade 9 and 10
students, Bill Hollingsworth expressed the view that most students will move toward academic programs
and away from applied programs. He noted that students are trying to complete compulsory courses as
soon as possible in order to graduate in four years. School staff are working with parents in helping
students to successfully plan their academic programs.
Trustee Libbey expressed the view that the secondary school experience will be negatively
affected by the Ministry's curriculum changes. He asked staff to provide information regarding the impact
of the curriculum changes on Grade 9 and 10 students. Superintendent Mason agreed to begin tracking the
issue.
In response to Trustee Libbey's query, Bob Powell pointed out that the OCDSB is working with
local universities in monitoring the double cohort situation. Marjore Clegg added that the OCDSB
requested feedback from other school boards about their double -cohort year strategies. Other school boards
are also in a "watch and wait" mode. Trustee Libbey requested that staff provide a status report regarding
the double -cohort year and its impact on OCDSB students.
With regard to staff development courses offered during the summer months, Trustee Sheryl
MacDonald expressed concern that course attendance may significantly decline as a result of the increasing
demands being placed on teachers. Superintendent Mason noted that last year's Summer Institute
attendance records indicate that there is a demand for the program. He noted his reluctance to predict the
results of next summer's program, but emphasized that the OCDSB's goal is to make training opportunities
available to teachers that best suit their needs. Trustee Sheryl MacDonald requested that staff monitor
workshop attendance and that they make the Ministry aware of any significant decrease in teachers'
participation in staff development opportunities.
With regard to the Ministry's recent announcement about regular testing of teachers, Tony Pearson
pointed out that teachers voluntarily update their credentials. He reported that the Upper Canada District
School Board recently approved a motion to send a letter to the Ministry indicating its opposition to
mandatory teacher testing. Mr. Pearson offered to make the wording of the motion available to the
members of the Education Committee. He noted that a similar motion from the OCDSB to the Ministry
would indicate this school board's confidence in its teachers ongoing efforts to maintain up to date
qualifications.
In response to Trustee Scott's query, Principal Dempsey confirmed that teachers and principals
from outside the OCDSB are charged a fee to attend OCDSB workshops and courses.
Superintendent Mason noted that the OCDSB wrote to the Ontario College of Teachers (OCT) last
year, requesting that the school board be certified as a delivery agency, with the intention of offering its
teachers staff development opportunities that would satisfy both OCT standards and certification
requirements at the same time.
Superintendent Mason commented on the professionalism of teachers in the OCDSB and he
thanked Marjorie Clegg, Margaret Dempsey, Robert Powell and members of their staff for their superb
accomplishments. Superintendent Mason noted that in 1998, trustees recognized the value and need for
staff development and he expressed appreciation to trustees for their ongoing support.
On a motion by Trustee Scott, the Committee members expressed their appreciation to
Superintendent Mason, Manager Marjorie Clegg, Principal Margaret Dempsey, and Principal Bob Powell
for their excellent work in their respective divisions.
Education Committee -5- 15 May 2000
8. School Profiles - Plan for 2000 -2001
Your Committee had before it for information staff report No. 00 -079 providing a model for
school profiles. The report contains the proposed design for elementary and secondary school 2000 -2001
profiles, as well as a list of the School Profile Committee members.
Superintendent Mason reported that a Committee consisting of the Board's stakeholders was
convened and that the Committee's recommendations have been incorporated into the new school profiles
format. He introduced Marjorie Clegg, who noted the following points:
• The Committee recommended that the profiles be as people- oriented as possible. Photos of
students will be included in the profiles, as well as the possible inclusion of a map indicating
the school's location;
• The EQAO results have been moved to the back of the profile and will include three years
data for Grade 3 and two years for Grade 6;
• The school improvement plans and initiatives section has been expanded.
• School mission statements will be included for those schools that have them.
Trustee Scott expressed her appreciation to staff and the Committee for the revised profiles. She
noted that the profiles are now more informative and reader - friendly. Trustee Scott noted that with the
increasing presence of information technology in the schools, libraries are becoming increasingly less
book - dependent so the emphasis in the school profiles should not focus solely on the number of books
available in a school's library.
Trustee Scott also suggested that the information provided regarding classes and programs for the
learning disabled and for the gifted be presented in a consistent and comparable fashion. If the number of
classes offered for one particular program is listed, the number of classes should also be listed for other
programs.
9. Graduate Sury ey
Your Committee had before it for information staff report No. 00 -83 presenting the results of a
December 1999 survey of OCDSB graduates, the questionnaire circulated to graduates, and
recommendations which will be followed up by the appropriate OCDSB departments.
Marjorie Clegg provided an overview of the report, noting that while the return rate of 22% was
very low, the overall results were predictable. For example, while a higher than average percentage of
graduates (78 %) reported that they would be enrolling in a post - secondary institution, the statistics were on
par with OCDSB results in the past. She reviewed the recommendations contained in the report, including
the circulation of the report to schools for use in school improvement planning, the investigation of
additional and alternate methods of collecting the data in future, the surveying of students who have left
school without earning a diploma, and the use of a student sample rather than a mailing to all graduates.
A brief discussion ensued about alternate methods of surveying graduates, including the
distribution of surveys via the Teacher Advisor Program (TAP), in high school homerooms, and the
eliciting of information for comparative purposes from the index cards that some high schools distribute to
students at their graduation ceremonies. A member noted the importance of eliciting the information from
the students after they had received university or college acceptance /rejection.
Staff noted that while the results of the survey were somewhat unreliable due to the low return
rate, the information will be used as part of the system audit in May and will also be useful to schools in
developing their improvement plans /profiles.
Education Committee -6- 15 May 2000
t I
10. Program Review of English LanauaRe Arts, Mathematics and Secondary School Reform
Your Committee had before it for information staff report No. 00 -051 presenting the program
reviews of English, Language Arts, Mathematics and the implementation of Secondary School Reform
(SSR). The program reviews were designed to describe best practices, assess the OCDSB's level of success
in achieving best practices, and make recommendations for areas of improvement. The report includes the
table of contents and summary of issues and recommendation from each of the program reviews. Members
were provided with binders containing the full program reviews at the 17 April 2000 Education Committee
meeting.
Superintendent Mason provided a synopsis of the staff report, noting that the program reviews
provide a basis for the activities that will be carried out by the Program, Quality Assurance, and Staff
Development divisions. The program reviews contain a wealth of information, including data on
curriculum, teaching strategies, assessment strategies, parental strategies, and learning resources, as well, in
the case of SSR, data regarding TAP, the Annual Education Plan (AEP), Community Involvement, and the
double cohort.
In response to Trustee Scott's query, Ms. Clegg clarified that the issues and recommendations are
suggestions, not mandates, and that the topics may be addressed in workshops. Superintendent Mason
noted the likelihood that the system audit will produce similar findings to the program reviews. He
described the recommendations as highlighting areas for improvement, for example, the role of schools in
reinforcing language arts and mathematics practices in the home.
Betty Tait expressed surprise at the inclusion of OCASC in some of the recommendations. She
suggested that OCASC's role in facilitating training, as opposed to providing training, be clarified
consistently throughout the summary of issues and recommendations sections of the reports.
The trustees commended Superintendent Mason and his staff for the report.
11. Children & Youth at Risk Advisory Committee Report
Your Committee had before it for information staff report No. 00 -128 providing a status report on
the recently formed Advisory Committee on Children and Youth at Risk, including a list of members.
Superintendent Hoye noted that in the fall of 1999, the OCDSB hosted three highly successful
breakfast forums, from which members of the community and business sectors were chosen for
consideration for membership by the Steering Committee. The Steering Committee has met on numerous
occasions to establish the mandate, terms of reference, responsibilities and composition of the Committee.
Superintendent Hoye briefly reviewed the list of Advisory Committee members and emphasized
that the members are highly committed to students at risk and to the OCDSB. She noted that the inaugural
meeting is scheduled for 15 June 2000. Superintendent Hoye expressed her hope that trustees and senior
staff would attend the meeting, particularly since there will be an opportunity to meet and speak with the
Advisory Committee members prior to the business portion of the meeting.
12. Proposal for Review of ESLELD 2000 -2001
Your Committee had before it for information staff report No. 00 -113 outlining the plan for the
review of ESLELD scheduled to take place in 2000 -2001. The process will include the establishment of a
Staff Program Evaluation Advisory Committee, a matrix for planning the data collection, and a draft action
plan.
Superintendent Mason introduced the report, noting that the date for submission of the report and
recommendations to the Education Committee had been moved forward to 15 January 2001 to ensure that
any implications for the budget are reviewed prior to the beginning of the budget process.
Education Committee -7- 15 May 2000
b� -
Marjorie Clegg noted that surveys would be circulated shortly to trustees, superintendents,
schools, OCASC, students, etc., requesting their input to the ESUELD review.
13. New Business
Trustee Libbey initiated a brief discussion of the Ministry's proposed Education Accountability
Act, 2000 and the merits of writing to the Ministry regarding the OCDSB's reaction to the proposed
legislation, including the issues of co- instructional activities, class size, instructional time, and school board
compliance. Members commented on the speed at which the legislation is being processed. Tony Pearson
noted that Constituency Week is scheduled for next week and suggested that the OCDSB request a meeting
with local MPPs while they are working in their respective ridings.
Trustee Libbey invited trustees, staff and association representatives to remain after the meeting to
discuss possible strategies and a letter to the Ministry regarding the proposed revisions to the Education
Act.
The meeting adjourned at 9:45 p.m.
Patty Anne Hill, Chair
Education Committee
ky /mins15mayftdoc
Education Committee -8- 15 May 2000
�y
•
M,_J
OTTAWA- CAnETON
DISTRICT SCHOOL BOARD
REPORT NO. 8
SPECIAL EDUCATION ADVISORY COMMITTEE
To: The Board
APPENDIX A
Date: 3 May 2000
A meeting of the Special Education Advisory Committee was held in the Sir Robert Borden High School
Library, 131 Greenbank Road, Nepean, commencing at 7:30 p.m. with Casey van der Grient in the Chair and the
following in attendance:
Trustee Members: Andrew Lam, Sheryl MacDonald and Lynn Scott
Other Trustees: Patty Anne Hill
Association Representatives: Jane Berman, Association for Bright Children; Casey van der Grient, Autism Society
Ontario; Jon Kidd, Ottawa Deaf Centre; Bruce Ernhofer, Down Syndrome Association; Patty Fraser, Easter Seal
Society; Nora Ann McKibbon, Epilepsy Ottawa - Carleton; Gregory Bonnah and Jane Naugler, Integration Action
Group; Bob Fraser, Learning Disabilities Association of Ottawa; Nancy Myers, Ontario Association for Families of
Children with Communication Disorders; Margot Humphreys, Ottawa - Carleton Assembly of School Councils;
Myrna Laurenceson, Ottawa - Carleton Association for Persons with Developmental Disabilities; Colleen Hendrick,
VIEWS for the Visually Impaired
Community Representatives: Evan Cooper, Bronwyn Funiciello and Debi Kirwan
Staff: James Grieve, Director of Education and Secretary of the Board; Superintendents Dan Mason and Katharine
Saunders, Laura McAlister, Principal, Special Education; Marjorie Clegg, Manager, Quality Assurance; Terry
Laughlin, Chief, Psychological Services; Dan Wiseman, Chief, Social Work; Eleanor Thomas, Research Associate;
Gloria Scharfe, Committee Coordinator
Non - Voting Representatives: Lynn Moran, Ontario Secondary Schools Teachers' Federation (Educational
Assistants); Michael Harrison, Ottawa - Carleton Elementary Principals' Association; Jacquie Hawken, Ottawa -
Carleton Elementary Teachers' Federation; Christine DiZazzo and Terry Greatrix, Professional Student Services
Personnel
Also Present: Steve Ardanaz and Diana Ardanaz, Sign Language Interpreters
Call to Order
Co -Chair Myrna Laurenceson called the meeting to order at 7:40 p.m. before Co -Chair Casey van der
Grient assumed the Chair.
2. Approval of Agenda
The Chair noted an LDAO motion regarding LD class placements by lottery should be added as item 11 d).
Nancy Myers requested the addition of three items of new business: Elementary Enrolment Projections for Special
Education, SELC Reassignments and Public Rally Notice.
On a motion by Margot Humphreys, the agenda was approved, as amended.
Special Education Advisory Committee - 1 3 May 2000
I o
Casey van der Grient assumed the chair.
Public Question Period
There were no questions from the public
Departmental Update
The Director commented on the Ontario budget announcements. Although the announcements
provided no detail, the Director surmised that the additional funding referred to new money for education,
over and above the amounts announced previously. Additional funding is to be used to reduce class size at
the primary level to an average of 24 students. The OCDSB average class size is now 25 and restaffmg
will be required if the money is made available for the 2000 -01 school year. There also appears to be more
funding for special education, in addition to the $40 million announced in March. The OCDSB share of the
March funding will be approximately $1 million and its share of the additional $70 million included in the
provincial budget could be approximately $2 million. If mitigation grants are not affected by the new
money, the Board could benefit. A possible $7 million additional funding would have a significant impact
on the $23 million shortfall predicted in the next Board budget. The Director noted that the majority of the
shortfall is in instructional salaries where the Ministry's allowable amount per teacher is much lower than
the actual expenditure, and in surplus school space. Finance Department staff is attempting to get
clarification on the budget announcements.
Laura McAlister reported that her group has been very involved in the ISA process, which had a
deadline of 28 April. Schools prepared 1914 claims of which 104 were rejected by the school and 478 by
central staff. Claims were prepared and reviewed by the schools, and then reviewed by central staff and by
the Principal of Special Education. Ms McAlister noted this year's process was an improvement over last
year but there is still work to be done, specifically in the area of matching ISA claim information to
information in other areas. Next year the process is expected to commence in September. -VM)
In response to queries, Ms McAlister advised that staff limitations were not a factor in the number
of claims prepared, but that additional staff would have reduced the extremely heavy workload of available
staff.
Responding to a question regarding sign language interpreters, Ms McAlister advised that there
were four claims for students who are hard of hearing. However, she clarified that ISA claims are based on
the needs of students, not as a request for specific support, and students other than identified ISA students
may also receive levels of support according to need.
Referring to the question of consistency between the ISA claim and the report card, Ms McAlister
agreed with a comment that in some cases, for instance, where a behavioural student's needs are adequately
met through intensive support, there might be a positive comment on the report card. Because of the
environment a pupil may be able to maintain control but in another environment might not. In general,
however, there should be consistency, particularly for ISA -3 students.
Dan Wiseman commented on the recent stabbing incident at Cairine Wilson S.S. In response to
questions from the committee, he advised that the Board has the capacity to respond to any serious incident
quickly and efficiently. There is also the capability within schools to respond to any circumstance, up to
and including a lockdown, although this was not required at Cairine Wilson as the incident occurred during
the lunch hour when most of the students were outside.
Superintendent Saunders confirmed that a plan is in place at all schools covering movement of
students, evacuations, etc. and each plan includes provision for students who require assistance. There is
also a process for dealing with suicide threats. Any urgent matter would take precedence over all other
matters.
Special Education Advisory Committee -2 3 May 2000
11 /.
The Director noted that there is no real way to prevent situations from occurring. This Board has
(W many very large secondary schools and they are a reflection of life. Staff is active in prevention and
intervention, e.g., there was increased vigilance by both staff and the police on the anniversary of the
Columbine tragedy. Further cuts in psychology and social work will have an impact on staff s ability to
respond to some requirements, but a tragic or urgent event will always take precedence. The Board has an
excellent response team and the Director complimented Dan Wiseman and Maggie Melenhorst on their
handling of the media at Cairine Wilson.
Superintendent Saunders noted there have been follow -up discussions in all secondary schools
regarding important issues such as anger management, affects of teasing, and what students should do if
they have cause for concern about a fellow student.
The Director acknowledged the suggestion made by Nancy Myers last year that students be
encouraged to reflect on kindness among their peers, but he believed that an in -depth approach is required.
There are issues of appearance, culture, race, and the like that stem from the community, and a need to
really understand what young people bring to the schools from their diverse backgrounds.
On a positive note, Dan Wiseman reminded the group that schools are generally very safe places.
Students who create unfortunate incidents make up less than 4/10 of 1% of the school population. Others
contribute positively to the learning environment in the schools. Ongoing vigilance is important, but
incidents such as those at Cairine Wilson must be viewed in perspective.
Terry Laughlin reported that his group recently held a Suicide Prevention Workshop.
Participants' feedback was excellent, indicating they found it very worthwhile. He also reported that there
are 12 itinerant EAs in the elementary panel who are deployed on a temporary basis, usually for a one -to-
two week period, on request. All 12 are now fully booked until the end of the school year.
5. Chair's Report
The Chair welcomed Bruce Ernhofer, the newly appointed representative of the Down Syndrome
Association. On behalf of the Committee, he expressed sympathy to SEAC's Committee Coordinator, Kim
Young, on the recent death of her father.
6. Review of Report No. 7, Special Education Advisory Committee, 5 April 2000
It was noted that questions by committee members and staff responses are not always included in
the SEAC reports. The Director advised that the report is intended to convey a summary of discussions at a
meeting. The report would also include any issues that require further action. The Chair suggested that if
there are questions which elicit information pertinent to the subject under discussion, the committee
coordinator will be asked to include these in the record of the meeting.
Business Arising
Jane Berman commented regarding item 6, paragraph 4, on page 2, that if SEAC has a position
regarding its participation in advisory committees, beyond simply wanting to be involved, the position
should be clarified. The Chair suggested this could form part of the discussion under agenda item 10.
Ms Berman noted that she had not requested a report on gifted programs offered at all OCDSB
schools as indicated in the last paragraph of page 2, but believed the committee would be interested in
seeing the report when it becomes available.
Referring to page 5, paragraph 5, Ms Berman clarified that the ABC did not wholly support the
lottery system for placing gifted students, but because the other alternatives offered could not be readily
implemented, ABC did not actively oppose the lottery option. She also asked about timelines for the gifted
program review mentioned on page 5, paragraph 10, and was advised that a draft of the work plan and
timelines should be available for review at the June SEAC meeting.
Special Education Advisory Committee -3 3 May 2000
7,;�.
Nancy Myers had questions regarding the Ministry's evaluation of ISA claims discussed on page
6. Laura McAlister advised that the Ministry believes about 1% of the student population may be eligible
for ISA claims, but this is not a mandatory amount. Ms Myers noted that the OCDSB submitted 1200
claims last year and the Ministry reviewed only 96 of these. She wondered if that is a statistically valid
number. The Ministry has not determined what number they will use this year. Some committee members
expressed interest in knowing how the OCDSB fares this year in comparison to other boards across the
province.
Trustee Lam indicated that OPSBA has compiled information on province wide percentages and
he would make it available to SEAC members.
Debi Kirwan requested that, in an effort to ensure that issues are addressed in a timely manner, a
running list of action items for both staff and SEAC, be circulated with each agenda package sent to
Committee members. Director Grieve expressed support for this initiative.
7. Special Education Comprehensive Plan Report
Your committee had before it for review, staff report no. 00 -104 outlining the Board's proposed
report to the Ministry regarding special education. Laura McAlister noted that a full comprehensive plan
was submitted to the Ministry last year and this year the Board is only responding to SEAC's concerns
regarding its involvement in developing programs and services as per the request of EDU through G.
Hurtubuise, Acting District Manager, Regional Office. The proposed response outlines discussions
between staff and SEAC representatives throughout the year. The deadline for submission is 15 May. Ms
McAlister agreed to include reference to the SEAC motion regarding waiting lists and the survey of special
education and SELC teachers.
It was pointed out that many of the items included in the proposed response did not involve SEAC
as a committee, although individual member organizations may have been involved. Committee members
generally agreed that the proposed response includes only an overview of the system, roles and
responsibilities, rather than SEAC involvement in program planning. While there was opportunity for
input, there was no interaction between SEAC and the special education department. They questioned
whether the submission adequately responds to the Ministry and reflects the SEAC perspective.
Nancy Myers moved THAT SEAC delegate responsibility to a sub -group of representatives to
produce a parallel submission to the Ministry under SEAC cover, by 15 May 2000.
The motion carried.
The motion includes a friendly amendment by Trustee Scott that due to the short time frame it
would be appropriate to delegate responsibility to a sub -group of representatives to prepare the response.
The sub - committee will report back to the committee in June.
Greg Bonnah, Margot Humphreys, Debi Kirwan, Myrna Laurenceson and Nancy Myers
volunteered to prepare the SEAC submission.
8. Survey for Review of Special Education and Student Services
Your committee had before it staff report no. 00 -107 providing draft surveys for collecting data on
the special education model in effect during the 1999 -2000 school year. Superintendent Mason and
Marjorie Clegg presented the report, advising that representatives of the positions being surveyed, DCS and
an outside consultant have reviewed the questions. They noted that only parents of special needs students
are being surveyed because of the difficulty of compiling survey questions that would be suitable for
parents of both special and regular needs students. A focus group will be established to solicit input from
parents of children who do not have special needs.
* correction
Special Education Advisory Committee -4 3 May 2000
73
The survey will be distributed as soon as possible to give respondents ample time to complete and
(W return the questionnaire. Input will be analyzed over the summer months and results will be available early
in the school year. All information provided in the surveys will be confidential and some of the questions
are open ended in order to receive input that will assist in improving special education within the OCDSB.
Specific suggestions for changes to the surveys were as follows:
SERTS
• include visual impairment, hearing impairment and DD as separate categories
• if parent and volunteer support has been identified as something that could impact on service delivery,
include a reference
• direct and indirect SERT support for ESL and Gifted should be broken out
SELC Teachers
• include visual impairment, hearing impairment and DD as separate categories
Classroom Teachers
• ask what their experience has been in relation to various changes, rather than asking their opinion
• include timetabling and itinerant teachers as having a possible impact on teaching
• ask how many years teaching experience they have and if they have any special education
qualifications
• question 3 does not give a picture of the range of movement of students in the class; include language
to solicit information as to the different types of service being provided —SELC, withdrawal, etc. and
how the teacher deals with these students as part of the classroom
Principals
• ask principals to comment on changes to special education support for regular classroom teachers
Student Services Personnel
• include itinerant EAs as survey recipients
Parents /Guardians
• range of exceptionalities should be cited at the beginning as some students have multiple disabilities
• will all parents understand what `exceptional' means?
• include a definition of Mild Intellectual Disability and LD so parents will understand the difference
• include a-reference to special schools, for information
• change the word `delay' to `disability' and `handicapped' to `disability'
• reference to specific school should be deleted or indicated as optional information
• parents cannot be expected to interpret needs of other students in a classroom
• ask parents to comment on extra help from an EA
• remove underlining and word `individual' from question 7
Members asked whether parents could be invited to send a copy of their completed questionnaire to SEAC
if they wished to do so. Superintendent Mason did not support this request as he believed receiving fragmented
information could lead to raised levels of expectations or concern. He preferred to have all the information collated
and to provide a full report in the fall.
Trustee Scott noted that Zone 1 was chosen as the pilot area for the staff proposed delivery model and
asked if Zone 1 survey data could be segregated for comparison with the rest of the zones. Staff agreed to this
suggestion.
The Chair thanked Superintendent Mason and his team; staff responded that they appreciated SEAC's
feedback.
(W * correction
Special Education Advisory Committee -5 3 May 2000
7h
9. Discussion of SEAC Focus on Impacting the Ministry Special Education Funding Formula
Myrna Laurenceson moved that
WHEREAS one of the roles of the OCDSB Special Education Advisory Committee is to advocate for the
highest qualify of education in OCDSB schools; and
WHEREAS the Ottawa - Carleton District School Board will be obliged to cut approximately $85 million
from its budget due to the implementation of Bill 160, including approximately $23 -24 million next year to
comply with the provinces education funding formula; and
WHEREAS Ottawa - Carleton schools are already seeing severe impacts as a result of program cuts
resulting from the funding formula; and
WHEREAS SEAC believes that these cuts will have a detrimental impact on the quality of education
offered by the OCDSB; and
WHEREAS three other Ontario school boards —most recently the Toronto District School Board —have
passed motions expressing grave concern about the impact of the funding formula;
Therefore be it resolved that SEAC:
i) Urge the OCDSB to commit itself in principle to no further reductions in programs and services
due to inadequate allocations in the provincial funding formula, aside from reductions resulting
from amalgamation, harmonization of programs and services, and prudent management decisions;
ii) Urge the OCDSB to work with other school boards across Ontario to support the Toronto DSB's
initiative;
iii) Urge the OCDSB to clearly and publicly define the level of local funding cuts beyond which it
would be unable to deliver the minimum level of service that Ottawa- Carleton students need and
the community has a right to expect;
iv) Support the decision of the OCDSB to mount an aggressive campaign to raise public awareness of
the impact of provincially mandated funding cuts on the local school system, and on the Ottawa -
Carleton community, and offer its support in that campaign.
The motion was carried.
10. Planning Process for 2001 -2002 Budget Process
The Chair suggested that SEAC should discuss ways of improving the budget process for next
year, and invited comment from the Director.
The Director noted that the Board is reviewing the process now and it is important that he and the
Trustees are aware of the type of improvements SEAC would like to see. The Board has asked that staff
put together an information campaign for residents of Ottawa - Carleton and SEAC may wish to discuss
elements of the campaign, what staff, SEAC and the Board can contribute, and what can be done
provincially to ensure Board and provincial processes will mesh.
There was a suggestion that the item be deferred to the June meeting at which time members
would be expected to provide concrete suggestions; however, some specific suggestions were put forward.
Jon Kidd suggested that the Board should prioritize its needs, with specific reference to special
education as a priority in comparison with other needs. He felt it would be impossible to approach Queen's
Park regarding the impacts of the funding formula unless the Board's needs are clearly enunciated and
prioritized.
Special Education Advisory Committee -6 3 May 2000
The Director agreed that a good budget process begins with a set of articulated priorities although
he cautioned that choices are becoming ever narrower because of funding cuts. Priorities have not been
established for next year but that is the intent.
Trustee members noted that the Board is comprised of 12 individuals and every Trustee has their
own priority list. Special education is obviously a priority as evidenced by the fact that almost all of the
SEAC motions were approved and $8.2 million was taken out of reserves and assigned to special
education.
It was suggested that the budget timetable should be improved as this year there were too many
important decisions made in the early hours of the morning at the end of very lengthy meetings. Because
of the tight timeframes, the SEAC Chair was unable to present important information regarding special
education needs. Trustee Scott advised that in the former CBE, there existed a sparingly used practice of
allowing a SEAC representative to contribute to trustee debate at board meetings, if major SEAC motions
were under discussion. The Director agreed that the budget timeframe is too compressed and to some
extent this is because budget finalization is tied to collective agreements and staffing. He believed that
budget completion in May or June might be helpful. Alternatively a sub - committee might be struck to deal
with various issues and receive input, with sub - committee recommendations being presented in a short,
formal budget process.
It was suggested that staff share its thinking with SEAC as early as possible to ensure that staff
and SEAC have ample time to work together to resolve problems. As well, when proposed motions are
brought to a SEAC meeting, it would be helpful to receive from staff and Trustee members' concrete
feedback on the implications. This would enable SEAC to draft clear, realistic motions that would result in
time being used more effectively during budget debates.
(W It was noted that SEAC's non - budget related motions were not dealt with expeditiously this year
because there were no Education Committee meetings during the budget process and even the Board
meetings seemed to focus on budget issues. A better process should be developed next year to ensure
regular business is not overtaken by the budget.
A comment was made regarding the apparent lack of interest on the part of parents, evidenced by
the small numbers of people in the gallery during budget meetings. The Director advised that many people
are unaware of the impact of the provincial funding model on their schools and children. This is one of the
major reasons for undertaking a public awareness campaign. He invited suggestions from members and
suggested they need not wait until the next SEAC meeting. Following further discussion, it was agreed that
Colleen Hendrick will e-mail all members inviting their suggestions on the budget process and the
awareness campaign. She will then compile all the responses and forward them to the Director who will
prepare a discussion paper for the June meeting.
11. Notices of Motion
a) Congregated Gifted Program Cap of 25 — Jane Berman
The motion was withdrawn.
b) Report on Students Removed from System Classes — Lamar Mason
Notice having been given, Margot Humphreys, substituting for Lamar Mason, moved that
WHEREAS SEAC will be monitoring and evaluating the ongoing implementation of the new
delivery model for special education;
(W Therefore be it resolved:
* correction
Special Education Advisory Committee -7 3 May 2000
76-
THAT the OCDSB identify all students removed from system classes at the end of the 1999 -2000
school year as a result of the reduction in such classes, and monitor their academic progress and
social integration over the 2000 -2001 school year; and
THAT a report on the progress of these students (with all due respect for confidentiality) be
brought to SEAC in time for the findings to be considered in its deliberations around the 2001-
2002 budget.
Ms Humphreys clarified that the motion referred only to students who would have remained in
system classes had those classes not been reduced in number because of budget cuts.
Trustee Scott moved that the motion be deferred to the June SEAC meeting to allow staff time to
review the implications of the motion.
The motion to defer carried.
C) Implementation of Results of IPRC — Greg Bonnah
The motion was deferred to the June meeting at the request of the mover.
d) Congregated LD Classes — Bob Fraser
Bob Fraser moved that
WHEREAS Learning Disabilities make up the largest group of special needs students in the
OCDSB; and
WHEREAS there are small, specialized, congregated class placements available for less than 2%
of all LD students; and
WHEREAS the Leaming Disabilities Association of Ottawa - Carleton has heard from parents that
their children's needs are not being meet in the SELC model introduced in September 1999 due to
the limitations inherent in the structure, range of needs and ages, and other factors identified by the
special education teachers surveyed in December 1999; and
WHEREAS the number of placements is statistically insignificant in relation to the number of
students who would benefit by the small class setting; and
WHEREAS the OCDSB has chosen to use a lottery system for the equitable placement of gifted
students in congregated classes; and
WHEREAS it must then become equitable for all LD students to be eligible for those few spots:
Therefore, be it resolved that
LD class placements be determined by lottery, in a similar fashion to what has been proposed as
an equitable response for the Gifted Congregated classes, and that the OCDSB send a similar
questionnaire to LD families of severe LD students (ISA 2 or 3) to see if they wish to participate
in the lottery for a small class placement.
Bob Fraser indicated the motion is self - explanatory and follows the precedent set for gifted
congregated placements.
There was some discussion regarding the timing of this motion as placements have already begun
through the normal IPRC process, and all placements must be completed by the end of June. Therefore, it
appears it is too late to act on the motion if it were approved. There are 27 students designated ISA -3 and
Special Education Advisory Committee -8 3 May 2000
these students would normally be directed to the congregated classes. There is a much larger number of
(W ISA -2 students. Mr. Fraser noted that gifted students are grouped by points on a scale where all students
are at approximately the same point. This is not the case with LD students and makes selection by lottery
difficult to implement. It was noted that there are 10 students competing for each LD congregated
placement.
The Chair suggested that if the motion was intended to draw attention to the fact that LD classes
are oversubscribed, the motion might be withdrawn and forwarded to Colleen Hendrick as part of the
budget process discussion material. Another suggestion was that an agenda item for June or September
could examine the proper placement of students by needs rather than by lotteries.
The motion was withdrawn.
12. Information Items
The committee received for information staff report no. 00 -103 containing the waiting list
template for gathering information on students requiring assessments. Information will be provided to
SEAC at its June meeting.
A number of handouts were also available for committee members:
• Advance Notice of Motion, Dispute Resolution for Disagreements in Implementation of the
IPRC;
• 8 May 2000 Public Rally Notice;
• Notes on Elementary Staffing for Special Education in Zone 1, by Trustee Scott;
• 2000 -2001 Resource Manual for the Special Education Grant Intensive Support Amount -
Guidelines for School Boards.
The meeting adjourned at 11:30 p.m.
/gs
Casey van der Grient, Co -Chair
Special Education Advisory Committee
Special Education Advisory Committee -9 3 May 2000
APPENDIX B
Report to Ministry of Education
Re: Ottawa - Carleton District School Board
Special Education Comprehensive Plan - May 2000
The Ministry of Education's response to the Ottawa - Carleton District School Board ( OCDSB) Comprehensive
Plan of May 1999 was provided in a letter to Director Grieve on 21 March 2000 from Gerald Hurtubise, Acting
District Manager. As a result of SEAC's motion not to approve this plan, the Ministry of Education requests
that the OCDSB provide a response to SEAC in terms of its involvement in developing programs and services in
the year 2000.
The following chronology presents the opportunities which were undertaken as part of the review of programs
and services between the OCDSB and its SEAC for the 2000 -2001 budget and special education delivery model
discussions. In addition to the issues noted below, beginning at its 5 October 1999 meeting, SEAC has been
involved in the formation of the Review of Special Education /Student Services 1999 -2000 including the Plan of
Action and Guiding Principles. As well, SEAC reviewed all questionnaires which formed part of the process.
SEAC will continue its involvement in this review as it moves into 2000 -2001.
5 October 1999
The SEAC meeting was entitled Roles. Responsibilities/Relationships. The content provided
background information pertaining to the legal responsibilities of SEAC. Considerable discussion
around a variety of issues took place.
26 October 1999
Workshop on Communications. The structure of this evening provided an opportunity to receive
information on such issues as the drafting of motions. It further provided opportunity for the
associations to dialogue around communication issues as they related to special education.
3 November 1999
SEAC Guiding Principles were distributed at this meeting and the draft SEAC mission statement was
presented.
1 December 1999
The focus of this meeting centred on the term 'advisory'. At this same meeting, SEAC reviewed
Guiding Principles regarding the Budget Process.
16 December 1999
The Budget Forecast and the report on the Implementation of the OCDSB Special Education Delivery
Model were presented to SEAC by Director Grieve and Superintendent of Finance, Michael Clarke
(attached as Appendix A).
6 January 2000
Members of SEAC, on behalf of their associations, presented information in response to the Budget
Forecast and the Special Education Delivery Model.
17 January 2000
SEAC presentation to Education Committee
2 February 2000
Additional staffing information was presented to SEAC regarding the staff- proposed delivery model.
1 & 2 March 2000
SEAC motions regarding Itinerant Programs of Service, Centres of Excellence, and the reinstatement
of speech and language pathology support for children aged nine years and older were introduced.
Further discussion around the implications of the Special Education Delivery Model and proposed
amendments took place. The results of the Special Education /Student Services Program Review
Surveys of Special Education Resource Teachers and Special Education Learning Centres were
presented to SEAC.
9 March 2000
SEAC motions with regard to the reinstatement of Special Education staff were introduced.
The budget process at the OCDSB provides that a budget observer, appointed by SEAC, participate as an active
member of the Committee of the Whole (Budget) as a non -voting representative. A representative from SEAC
provided valuable and considered input to the Board throughout the budget process.
In addition, SEAC's response to the staff - proposed delivery model was presented in the form of a delegation to
the Board at its 20 March 2000 Committee of the Whole (Budget) meeting.
Furthermore, several motions which had been formulated at the SEAC meetings of March 2000 were forwarded
directly to the COW (Budget) meeting.
The following SEAC recommendations were approved by the Board on 29 March 2000.
1. Reinstatement of Special Education Positions & Speech and Language Pathology Support
THAT the OCDSB Special Education Budget Allocation for 2000 -2001 be modified as follows:
A. THAT 19 teachers to be added as central program support teachers be deleted, leaving
a net increase of 4 teachers
B. THAT 6 Kindergarten Language Headstart /LLD teachers /classes be reinstated, for a
net reduction of 1.5 teachers /classes
C. THAT 6 General Learning Program teachers /classes be reinstated for a net loss of 2
teachers /classes
D. THAT 3 Primary Assessment Centre teachers /classes be reinstated, for a net loss of 2
teachers /classes
E. THAT 4 speech and language pathologist positions be reinstated
F. THAT all central staff currently identified under system and school support teams be
responsible for delivering service directly to the school level through training to
teachers, direct assistance on curriculum modification to teachers, assessment of
students, etc.
G. THAT the OCDSB reinstate speech and language pathology support for children aged
nine years and older who would benefit from such support.
Implementation: Sept. 2000
2. Itinerant Programs of Service
A. THAT during the 2000 -2001 school year, the OCDSB investigate the potential for
specialized itinerant programs to serve students with exceptionalities other than visual
or hearing impairment.
Review: 2000 -2001
3. Centres of Excellence
A. THAT the Board explore the concept of "Centres of Excellence" to serve exceptional students in
cost - effective, congregated settings, as part of the ongoing review of the delivery of special
education in the OCDSB: and
B. THAT the OCDSB leadership team work with the Special Education Advisory Committee and
stakeholders to investigate the design parameters of "Centres of Excellence" for exceptional
students.
Review: 2000 -2001
4. Waiting Lists
A. THAT the Board immediately begin to compile, maintain and update on a regular basis, as well
as to share with SEAC three times per school year, beginning in May 2000, numbers of students
awaiting specialized assessments and /or supports, as well as obtaining and maintaining
Ou.
information regarding the number of students being supported in SELCs, and the number of
applications for SELCs, system and specialized classes; and
B. THAT this information contain a breakdown of each category on the basis of exceptionality and
include the filing date of the longest waiting application.
Implementation: May 2000
Further to the motions listed above, a motion was adopted by the Board on March 29, 2000 which provides for a
Pilot Project in one zone of the OCDSB in 2000 -2001. The examination of this pilot will provide further
information to SEAC and the Board with respect to future decisions around special education delivery. Given
the reduction of some specialized classes, this pilot will also provide opportunity for examination of special
education programs in alternate delivery models.
The May 2000 meeting of SEAC will begin the examination of the process for the budget deliberations for 2001-
2002.
16 May 2000