HomeMy WebLinkAboutBoard 30 Oct 2000 Minutes Public0
M,_j
OTTAWA-C MUETON
DISTRICT SCHOOL BOARD
MINUTES
30 OCTOBER 2000
30 October 2000
In a continuation of the Board meeting held 24/25 October, the Ottawa- Carleton
District School Board met this evening in the Board Room, 133 Greenbank Road, Nepean,
Ontario, commencing at 7:00 pm with Trustee Jim Libbey in the Chair, and the following in
attendance: Trustees Cynthia Bled (by phone), Albert Chambers, Alex Getty, Lynn Graham,
Patty Anne Hill, Russ Jackson, Andrew Lam, Norm MacDonald (by phone), Sheryl MacDonald,
Pam Morse, and Lynn Scott.
Student Representative: Ryan Gilmour
Staff: Director of Education and Secretary of the Board, Jim Grieve; Superintendents
Rose -Marie Batley, John Brennan, Michael Clarke, Ross Donaldson, Judith Hoye, Dan Mason,
Barbara Stollery, Judy Turriff, and Bonnie Viney; Labour Relations Officers, Janet Beer and
Keith Egli; Manager, Physical Planning & Transportation, Mike Carson; Principals Laura
McAlister and Mike Neill; Assistant Secretary of the Board, Joan Melancon; Manager, Communi-
cations & Information Services, Maggie Melenhorst; Administrator of Labour Relations, Carol
Murphy' Management, Policy and Planning Advisor, Janice Sargent; Technician, Robert Giekes;
and Committee Coordinators Bruce Fraser (in camera) and Brenda Cooper (public session).
Legal Advisor Roger Mills was present for the in camera session.
On a motion by Trustee Sheryl MacDonald, seconded by Trustee Chambers, the Board
resolved into Committee of the Whole to consider the items on the in camera agenda. Trustee
Graham assumed the Chair in the Committee, and the Committee later rose and presented the
report which follows (Board minute 357 -00 refers).
356. Call to Order
Chair Libbey called the meeting to order, and noted that the meeting was a
continuation of the Board meeting of 24/25 October 2000.
Unanimous consent to add an item regarding extraordinary meetings of the Board was
not granted. (Note: consent was granted later, see Board minute 372 -00 below.)
357. Report No. 18 Committee of the Whole Camera) Continuation
Trustee Graham presented Report No. 18, Committee of the Whole (in camera), viz:
Special Education Appeal
(Motion by Trustee Lam, seconded by Trustee Norm MacDonald)
A. THAT the Board uphold the IPRC determinations of 8 and 9 May 2000 that the
placement of two students be "regular classroom with appropriate support ";
293
6
ML
OTTAWA CAUETON
DISTRICT SCHOOL BOARD
MINUTES
30 OCTOBER 2000
B. THAT the Board support staff's pursuance of alternatives, based on sections (a)
to (d) of the Special Education Appeal Board's recommendations, to maximize
the "appropriate support" for these students within the Board's available
resources; and
C. THAT staff proceed as directed in Committee of the Whole (in camera) with
respect to the determinations of the Special Education Appeal Board held on
10 October 2000.
At the request of Trustee Sheryl MacDonald, a separate recorded voted was held on
each part of the motion. The motion was carried on the following division:
Part A
FOR: Trustees Chambers, Getty, Jackson, Lam, Libbey,
and Scott 6
AGAINST: Trustees Graham, Hill, and Sheryl MacIonald 3
ABSTENTIONS: Trustees Bled and Norm MacDonald 2
Part B
FOR: Trustees Chambers, Getty, Jackson, Lam, and Libbey 5
AGAINST: Trustees Graham, Hill, Sheryl MacDonald, and Scott 4
ABSTENTIONS: Trustees Bled and Norm MacDonald 2
Part C
FOR: Trustees Chambers, Getty, Jackson, Lam, Libbey,
and Scott 6
AGAINST: Trustees Graham, Hill, and Sheryl MacDonald 3
ABSTENTIONS: Trustees Bled and Norm MacDonald 2
It was noted that the Board would be returning to Committee of the Whole (in camera)
following the public session (reference Board minutes 370 -00 and 371 -00 below).
Note: The following six items, Board minutes 358 -00 through 363 -00 are follow up issues from
the Area Review /School Closure process.
358. Board Member Motion, Partial Disvo-sition _fPoverty. Trustee Chambers
Notice of motion having been given, Trustee Chambers, seconded by Trustee Norm
MacDonald, moved as follows
294
IC
F1
4
M,—J
OTTAWA CARLETON
DISTRICT SCHOOL BOARD
MINUTES
30 OCTOBER 2000
THAT staff be directed to report to the November Business Services Committee with a
proposal for the partial disposition of the "North" Wing of Fisher Park School and
rationale for this action as being a unique situation given the previous history of the
site (e.g. closure, disposition, return, re- opening for a different purpose, etc.) and its
status as a leasehold.
Trustee Chambers noted that this was follow -up to an earlier motion on which some
work has been done. He felt that the Board should now explore how the OCDSB can make an
effective case to the Ministry for partial disposition of Fisher Park with the accompanying
removal of pupil places from the Board's inventory.
In response to questions, Superintendent Batley reported that normally if the Ontario
Real Estate Board or one of the preferred agencies acquire the property, the pupil places come
off the inventory. In this instance the Board has been advised that its inventory will be
adjusted only if the space is taken by a school board for use as a regular day school. Since the
coterminous English board is unwilling to co- locate, and since the wing in question is principally
classroom space and lacks specialty space, it is less desirable. None of the coterminous boards
have ever expressed interest in Fisher Park.
Superintendent Batley reported that there are 338.5 pupil places in the wing in
question.
Trustee Chambers recalled that Fisher Park's situation was unique. It had been closed
as a secondary school by the predecessor board and transferred to another school board. It was
later returned to the former OBE and partially reopened as an elementary school. He noted
that if the school had been returned after amalgamation and the new accommodation formula,
the pupil places would not be on the Board's inventory. For this reason, he felt that perhaps
a different case could be made to the Ministry.
Some trustees questioned whether anyone would want to have a portion of a school.
Trustee Hill noted that the daycare centre at Devonshire needs to be relocated, and
asked whether they could rent part of a wing at Fisher Park. Superintendent Batley advised
that following the closure of a school with daycare, staff will meet with the operators to
determine whether there is a suitable site for relocation.
At the request of Trustee Scott, a recorded vote was held and the motion carried on the
following division:
FOR: Trustees Bled, Chambers, Graham, Hill, Libbey,
Norm MacDonald, and Sheryl MacDonald 7
AGAINST: Trustees Getty, Jackson, and Scott 3
ABSTENTION: Trustee Lam 1
295
0
ML
OTTAWA CARLETON
DISTRICT SCHOOL BOARD
MINUTES
30 OCTOBER 2000
Trustee Chambers had given notice of motion regarding the immediate disposition of
the Brook Lane and Borden properties. In response to his inquiry, staff advised that both have
been placed on the list of properties to be sold, although no action will be taken on the Borden
site until 15 July 2001. Trustee Chambers advised that he was not placing his motion on the
floor because it was redundant.
360. Review of Administrative and Other Sites
Notice of motion having been given, Trustee Chambers, seconded by Trustee Graham,
moved as follows:
A. THAT staff be directed to report to the January 2001 Business Services
Committee with a needs assessment and a draft disposition plan for the
following sites:
(i) 2221 Elmira Drive (formerly Queensway School);
(i i) 1224 Main Street, Stittsville (Depot);
(iii) 605 Bronson Avenue (Bronson Shops & Media Centre);
B . THAT staff be directed to report to the January 2001 Business Services
Committee with their preliminary views on the retention or disposition of 440
Albert Street; and
C. THAT staff be authorized to engage the services of professional property
management consultants to assist them in preparing these reports.
Trustee Chambers reported that he wished to see a report for the new Board on plans
for the administrative sites in part A, including a needs assessment. With respect to the Albert
Street site, he recalled that it is being held pending the secondary school review. He noted
that it would be helpful to have a preliminary idea of how it could be used. Part C would
authorize engaging professional help if staff resources were insufficient.
Staff noted that with only 350 pupil places, Albert Street could be a beneficial location
for a system program.
Changes to the timing and venue for the reports in parts A and B were accepted as
friendly amendment.
Upon being advised that staff have the scope to engage professional services, Trustee
Chambers withdrew part C of the motion with the consent of the meeting.
Trustee Hill noted that schools in Stittsville are overcrowded, and asked whether the
depot could be converted to a school, at least on a short term basis. Staff advised that there
would be zoning issues, and that renovation costs would be significant. Trustee Scott recalled that
the building had previously been a car dealership, and that it is in a commercial area.
296
F1
0
M—j
OTTAWA- CARLETON
DISTRICT SCHOOL BOARD
MINUTES
30 OCTOBER 2000
At the request of Trustee Norm MacDonald, separate votes were held for parts A(i),
A(ii) /(iii), and B. The motion was carried, viz:
D. THAT staff be directed to report to the appropriate January or February
Committee meeting with a needs assessment and a draft disposition plan for
the following sites:
(i) 2221 Elmira Drive (formerly Queensway School);
(ii) 1224 Main Street, Stittsville (Depot);
(iii) 605 Bronson Avenue (Bronson Shops & Media Centre);
E. THAT staff be directed to report to the appropriate January or February
Committee meeting with their preliminary views on the retention or
disposition of 440 Albert Street.
Two notices of motion having been given, Trustee Chambers, seconded by Trustee
Graham, combined the two motions and moved as follows,
THAT staff be directed to provide a brief progress report to the November Business
Services Committee and a more complete written report to the appropriate committee
in December 2000 on the disposition of 330 Gilmour Street and options for the relocation
of the remaining services located at the former Borden H.S. (515 Cambridge Street
South).
Following review of the timing with staff, a friendly amendment by Trustee Scott
regarding a brief progress report in November and a more complete written report in December
was accepted (the amendment has been incorporated into the motion above).
The motion was carried.
Trustee Scott had advised that she would have motions regarding the disposition of
schools. She advised that in view of the amendments to Trustee Chambers' motions (above), no
further motions would be required.
Trustee Scott expressed concern about a recent article in the Ottawa Citizen, and a
rumour that she would be proposing reconsideration. If someone had asked her intent in
referring to the disposition of property, the issue could have been cleared up.
297
0
LM
OTTAWA CARLETON
DISTRICT SCHOOL BOARD
363. Consultation with Affected Communities re
Program & Student Relocations, Trustee Graham
MINUTES
30 OCTOBER 2000
As a follow up to her question at the 25 October Board meeting regarding consultation
with the school communities affected by school closures, Trustee Graham asked about
opportunities for school councils to meet with staff regarding program and student relocations.
Superintendent Batley noted that a session would be held with affected school councils
and principals on 16 November to obtain their feedback on possible options. It was noted that
receiving schools will be included in the meeting. Input that has already been received will
also be taken into consideration in developing preliminary options. Further input can be sent
directly to Superintendent Batley but must be received within the next week or so.
Superintendent Batley reported that staff would bring back all recommendations on
student relocation to the 28 November Board meeting.
In response to further questions, staff agreed that input already received with regard to
Elmdale and Overbrook would be reviewed as well as any further material they wished to
submit, but they would not be included in the 16 November meeting.
364. Report No. 2, S12ecial Purpose Budget Committee, 3 October 2000
On a motion by Trustee Morse, seconded by Trustee Scott, the Board received Report No. 2
from the Special Purpose Budget Committee, dated 3 October 2000.
There were no recommendations in the report.
365. Report No. 6. Business Services Committee. 11 October 2000
On a motion by Trustee Morse, seconded by Trustee Scott, the Board received Report No. 6
from the Business Services Committee, dated 11 October 2000.
Trustee Morse presented and seconded the recommendation in the report, viz:
(Motion by Trustee Scott in substitution for Trustee Libbey)
A. THAT the Board direct staff to submit the OCDSB's interim Long Term
Accommodation Plan (LTAP), as amended, to the Ministry of Education; and
B . THAT staff proceed with the preparation of the Facilities Master Plan in
accordance with the process outlined in the LTAP.
P]
298
0
M'I-j
OTTAWA CAUETON
DISTRICT SCHOOL BOARD
MINUTES
30 OCTOBER 2000
Trustees were pleased to see the report, and look forward to seeing the proposed
priorities. Trustee Scott noted that there are a number of urgent issues including the secondary
review, new schools and renovations, and that she hopes the Board will take the necessary
actions soon.
The recommendation was adopted by the Board.
366. Report No. 6. Education Committee, 16 October 2000
On a motion by Trustee Hill, seconded by Trustee Norm MacDonald, the Board received
Report No. 6 from the Education Committee, dated 16 October 2000.
Trustee Hill presented and seconded the recommendations in the report, viz:
(a) Report No 11 Special Education Advisory Committee, 4 October 2000
(Motion by Trustee Scott)
THAT Report No. 11 of the Special Education Advisory Committee, dated
4 October 2000, be received.
(b) A New Vision for Secon ary Schools
(Motion by Trustee Graham)
A. THAT report No. 00- 227 "Presentation of a New Vision for Secondary
Schools in the OCDSB" be approved for distribution to OCDSB
personnel and partners groups, as indicated in The Need for
Consultation section of the report.
B . THAT the suggested process for feedback and timelines be approved,
with the change in the date of the collection and analysis of feedback
deadline to 28 February 2001.
(c) Co- located Re lar English and Alternative Programs
(Motion by Trustee Chambers)
THAT beginning in September 2001, co- located Regular English and Alternative
Programs be staffed by applying the elementary staffing formula to each
program independently.
With respect to "A New Vision for Secondary Schools ", Trustee Morse requested that
the report contain a more comprehensive list of options, rather than a narrower one. She
suggested, for example, that she would like to see the report changed so that it offers options
besides semestering, and so that it is less prescriptive. Superintendent Mason advised that her
suggestions would be incorporated in the second version before it is sent for consultation, and that
other options would be considered as they are received.
299
0
ML
OTTAWA CAUETON
DISTRICT SCHOOL BOARD
Trustees congratulated staff on an excellent report.
MINUTES
30 OCTOBER 2000
Recommendations (a) and (b) were adopted by the Board. On a motion by Trustee
Chambers, seconded by Trustee Scott, recommendation (c) was referred to the in camera session
to be held later.
As a matter of business arising from the Education Committee report, Trustee Morse
expressed disappointment that a staff report providing additional information about the
international baccalaureate program had not accompanied her motion at the Education
Committee.
i. '-I e • KINT- 1-- P 1i �� 111
On a motion by Trustee Scott, seconded by Trustee Getty, the Board received Report No. 5
from the Audit Committee, dated 11 October 2000.
There were no recommendations in the report.
368. School Choice Trustee Jackson
Notice of motion having been given, Trustee Jackson, seconded by Trustee Norm
MacDonald, moved as follows:
THAT the OCDSB hereby introduces a policy of school choice, which is to be
implemented by principals of the receiving schools subject to the following criteria:
A. cross - boundary transfers are to be approved on a first come, first served basis;
B . approval of a cross - boundary application is subject to class capacity or, in
instances where said application would impact on class organization, school
capacity;
C. where approval would trigger an increase in teacher allocation at the receiving
school, said application must be made in accordance with then existing staffing
timelines; and
D. for greater certainty, cross boundary transfers are not entitled to transportation.
Trustee Hill requested that recorded votes be held throughout debate.
Noting that the Business Services Committee had scheduled consideration of the
designated school /transfer policy at its next meeting, Trustee Morse, seconded by Trustee Getty,
moved THAT the motion be referred to the 8 November meeting of the Business Services
Committee, for consideration in the context of the existing policy and any changes recommended
by staff.
11
0
Lm"-j
OTrAWA-CARLETON
DISTRICT SCHOOL BOARD
MINUTES
30 OCTOBER 2000
Staff confirmed that a report for the 8 November meeting was in progress, but noted
that it was taking a different direction than Trustee Jackson's motion, and requested clear
direction tonight regarding revisions.
A recorded vote was held and the motion to refer was defeated on the following
division:
FOR: Trustees Getty, Graham, Morse, and Scott 4
AGAINST: Trustees Chambers, Hill, Jackson, Lam, Libbey, and
Norm MacDonald 6
ABSTENTION: Trustee Sheryl MacDonald
Trustee Hill noted concerns about the proposed change, i.e., school choice may be
inequitable because some students will not be able to afford transportation, and how school
choice will fit with secondary school reform. She suggested that there are different
circumstances for urban and rural students, and that this should be reflected in policy.
Superintendent Mason reported that equity and transportation have been identified as
issues for consideration when undertaking program rationalization.
A number of trustees indicated that they liked the proposed change, but shared Trustee
Hill's concern about equity, especially for rural, and some suburban students.
When asked for comment, staff noted that the deadlines for cross - boundary transfers
must be established with 1 April staffing timelines in mind.
Trustee Morse, seconded by Trustee Hill, moved in amendment that Part D of the motion
regarding transportation be deleted. The amendment was carried on the following division:
FOR: Trustees Getty, Graham, Hill, Morse, Sheryl MacDonald,
and Scott 6
AGAINST: Trustees Chambers, Jackson, Lam, Libbey, and
Norm MacDonald 5
ABSTENTIONS: Nil 0
Trustee Morse, seconded by Trustee Getty, moved in amendment that "elementary" be
inserted before each instance of "cross- boundary transfer ". Trustee Morse explained that she
was doing this because there has not been an opportunity to address secondary school issues yet.
A recorded vote was held and the amendment was defeated on the following division:
FOR: Trustees Getty, Morse, and Scott 3
AGAINST: Trustees Chambers, Graham, Hill, Jackson, Lam, Libbey,
Norm MacDonald, and Sheryl MacDonald 8
ABSTENTIONS: Nil 0
301
0
ML
OTTAWA- CARLETON
DISTRICT SCHOOL BOARD
MINUTES
30 OCTOBER 2000
Trustee Scott, seconded by Trustee Getty, moved in amendment that A. school choice be
approved in principle, B. with direction to staff regarding draft policy revisions and an
analysis of the impact of implementing the amended criteria, and including for consideration
the original criteria proposed by Trustee Jackson.
Chair Libbey left the meeting, and Trustee Graham assumed the Chair. A recess was
held from 11:35 pm to 11:55 pm to enable Trustee Scott's proposed amendment to be duplicated
for the members.
Trustee Scott suggested that part D, now removed from the original motion, should be
included in the criteria. Others pointed out that since part D was no longer part of the original
motion, it should not be included. There was consensus that the word "original" before criteria
be removed and the last part of B rephrased: "the criteria as amended ".
Two friendly amendments by Trustee Chambers were accepted, viz: to change "approve
introducing, in principle ", to "approve, in principle; and to direct the revisions to the Business
Services Committee in December.
Recorded votes were held on Trustee Scott's amendment and on the main motion, as
amended, and the amendment, and the main motion as amended, and both were carried
unanimously, viz:
FOR: Trustees Chambers Getty, Graham, Hill, Jackson, Lam,
Norm MacDonald, Sheryl MacDonald, Morse, and Scott 10
AGAINST: Nil 0
ABSTENTIONS: Nil 0
The motion approved by the Board was as follows:
A. THAT the OCDSB hereby approve, in principle, a policy of school choice;
B . THAT staff be directed to bring draft revisions of relevant existing policies in
this area to the Business Services Committee in December 2000 together with
an analysis of the impact of implementing the criteria as amended.
Note: The following criteria are among those to be considered:
(i) cross - boundary transfers are to be approved on a first come, first served
basis;
302
0
LM"-J
OTTAWA CARLETON
DISTRICT SCHOOL BOARD
MINUTES
30 OCTOBER 2000
(ii) approval of a cross - boundary application is subject to class capacity or,
in instances where said application would impact on class organization,
school capacity;
(iii) where approval would trigger an increase in teacher allocation at the
receiving school, said application must be made in accordance with
then existing staffing timelines.
369. Motion to Continue Pact 11.00 pm and go into Committee of the Whole (In Camera)
Trustee Scott, seconded by Trustee Getty, moved that the meeting continue past 11:00
pm, and that the Board go back into Committee of the Whole (in camera). Trustee Morse
assumed the Chair in Committee, and the Committee later rose at 12:20 am and presented the
following report.
1 . Continuation of •mm of • s Camera), Report No.
Trustee Morse presented the report on the continuation Report No. 18, Committee of the
Whole (in camera), and seconded the recommendation in the report, viz:
Appointment of Supervisory Officers
(Motion by Trustee Scott)
A. THAT Laura McAlister be appointed to the role of supervisory officer effective
1 December 2000; and
B. THAT Nancy MacLeod be appointed to the role of supervisory officer effective
1 December 2000, subject to her agreement with the terms and conditions of
employment approved at the 30 October 2000 in camera session.
The recommendation was adopted by the Board.
371. Further Continuation of Committee of the Whole (In Camera) Report No 18
The Board then returned to Committee of the Whole (in camera) with Trustee Morse in
the Chair. The Committee later rose and advised that there was nothing further to report.
372. Provision for Calling Extraordinary Meetings
Unanimous consent now having been granted to consider this item, Trustee Morse,
seconded by Trustee Chambers, moved as follows:
303
0
ML
OTTAWA- CARLETON
DISTRICT SCHOOL BOARD
MINUTES
30 OCTOBER 2000
THAT the Board invoke the provisions in the Board's By -laws for the calling of
extraordinary meetings of the Board for discussion of labour relations issues for the
period from 30 October 2000 to 31 January 2001 inclusive
The motion was carried.
The meeting adjourned at 2:35 am.
James P. Grieve, Director of Education Jim Libbey
& Secretary of the Board Chair of the Board
BLC /cb
BE- 001030
304
P]