HomeMy WebLinkAbout‘We need to start acting on this’: Expert backs former trustee’s call to test for lead in Alberta’s school drinking water - Toronto Star - 04/25/2018 - Toronto Star - 04/25/20184/25/2018 `We need to start acting on this': Expert backs former trustee's call to test for lead in Alberta's school drinking water I The Star
TI If, STAR EDMONTON IK
This copy is for your personal non-commercial use only. To order presentation -ready copies of
Toronto Star content for distribution to colleagues, clients or customers, or inquire about
permissions/licensing, please go to: www.TorontoStarReprints.com
'We need to start acting on this:
Expert backs former trusteels call to
test for lead in Alberta's school
drinking water
dangerously
Tests in Ontario and B.C. last year revealed dozens of schools had drinking water
sources with .a
Testing in Ontario and B.C. last year found dangerous levels of lead in dozens of
schools, but e tests. never b.. requiredf., MCCONNELL
/ TORONTO STAR)
https://www.thestar.com/ed monton/2018/04/25/we-need-to-start-acting-on-this-expert-backs-former-trustees-cal I -to -test -for -lead -i n-albertas-school-dri nking-water. html
4/25/2018 'We need to start acting on this': Expert backs former trustee's call to test for lead in Alberta's school drinking water I The Star
By KEVIN MAIMANN StarMetro Edmonton
Wed., April 25, 2ol 8
EDMONTON — A former Edmonton Catholic School Board trustee wants to get the lead
out.
Marilyn Bergstra is pushing for mandatory third -party lead testing in Alberta schools
after researching the dangers of lead in water as part of a master's program at the
University of Waterloo.
Testing in Ontario and B.C. last year found dangerous levels of lead in dozens of schools,
but the tests have never been required in Alberta.
"Common sense would tellwe have a shared infrastructure going back to that
period in time, and if both Ontario and B.C. have tested with alarming results ... there's a
good chance Alberta would share similar results," Bergstra said.
Marc Edwards, a civil and environmental engineer at Virginia Tech who is an expert on
lead in water, said every province should test its schools. He worked with Ontario when
the province started testing several years ago and has helped strengthen water safety
there.
"If you're not hearing about lead in school water, that's bad news. Because if you test for
it, you will find it," Edwards said. "We need to start acting on this."
Edwards said lead adversely affects every system in the human body, and kids are
especially susceptible. According to the World Health Organization, children absorb up
to five times more ingested lead than adults.
A Government of Alberta health website notes symptoms are easy to miss in children but
can include lower intelligence, smaller size, behavioural problems, learning problems
and a lack of energy. Canada's maximum acceptable concentration for lead in drinking
water is o.ol mg/L, but Edwards said there is no safe level of lead for children.
"That's not to be alarmist. We all were lead -exposed when we ewe ere kids, moreso than
todaffli. Gee
nerallgr . , lead ttosurfrom all sourcs, All of thesthi
P w're exe !�ms are
true," Edwards said. "But it is generally considered time to take this bull by the horns
https://www.thestar.com/edmonton/20l8/O4/25/we-need-to-start-acting-on-this-expert-backs-former-trustees-call-to-test-for-lead-in-albertas-school-drinking-water.html
4/25/2018 'We need to start acting on this': Expert backs former trustee's call to test for lead in Alberta's school drinking water I The Star
Edwards said the problem with schools is not that they are likely to have lead pipes —
those are mostly in single-family detached homes — but that their plumbing is likely to
contain galvanized iron, solder and leaded brass.
"Lead leeching gets worse the more the water sits around. And schools are bad because
water sits around a lot, especially int e warm summer months, for example," he said.
"So we pretty often find high levels of lead in schools, and you almost expect that. There
are very few exceptions."
Lead pipes were used in many structures through the 195os, and lead soldering was used
on copper pipes until the mid-1970s in Canada.
Edmonton Catholic Schools spokesperson Lori Nagy said 59 of the district's 96 schools
were built before 1975. Nagy said the district does a Hazardous Materials Survey that
looks at lead as well as asbestos and other materials. She said the tests have never found
lead levels that exceed Canada's guidelines. Not every school in the district has been
tested, however.
:Jill
confident in the safety of the drinking water in all of the district's schools. Rosa said
water quality is tested "as needed at critical points in a school's lifecycle," such as during
0
Rosa said custodial staff flush water lines after summer, winter and spring breaks — a
practice recommended by Health Canada.
TiTrEii,Tfr(;Tn-im.plr pal -L in a TUM/ ( IF)W7dYMI RTTI�
water quality with EPCOR, the University of Alberta and Capital Health, which found its
water -quality standards are "acceptable."
Public health physician Louis Francescutti said authorities are likely hesitant to require
testing for two reasons: redoing plumbing is expensive, and some people are likely to file
lawsuits once they find out their kids were exposed to lead.
Tesperislin in ail Fina C 11
and dayeares can contract private accredited laboratories to do lead analysis, and
Alberta Health can help interpret results.
He said the province is currently "developing options" to support schools in assessing
the risk of lead exposure through drinking water.
https://www.thestar.com/edmonton/20l8/O4/25/we-need-to-start-acting-on-this-expert-backs-former-trustees-call-to-test-for-lead-in-albertas-school-drinking-water.html
4/25/2018 'We need to start acting on this': Expert backs former trustee's call to test for lead in Alberta's school drinking water I The Star
"As a first step, we are reviewing existing data on lead in drinking water from previous
1 116111 111 1111111111111 M
Last September, an investigation ordered by the B.C. government showed drinking water
in more than half of the province's school districts had unsafe levels of lead. Two
districts exceeded the acceptable limit by more than 50 per cent.
anc?�!ycares 77,41.7tario taile to meet provinciai Yeaci stanciarc[s, ciespite Vintarnio Waving
Canada's most stringent program for monitoring lead in school drinking water. Some
schools had lead concentrations up to 300 times higher than the threshold of io parts
per billion. 0
I OEM=
"They tend to go to older schools, they live in older homes, sothe situation is
exacerbated," she said.
Galvanized iron pipes are coated with zinc that sometimes has one per cent lead by
weight or more. Their use has been uncommon since the 1970s, as plastic and copper are
seen as superior materials for piping, but Edwards said some communities allowed
galvanized iron as recently as last year.
Leaded brass had lead purposely added to make it easier to maufacture intricate
plumbing parts until as recently as 2014. Brass pipes used in new buildings no longer
have added lead but still contain small amounts.
Solder is the glue used on copper pipes, and it typically had 50 per cent lead by weight
until
r# The lue can seep inside the pipes at high levels, depending e
on th
g
ead more about: Edmonton, Albert�
https://www.thestar. com/ed monton /201 8/04/25/we- n eed-to-sta rt -a cti ng -on -th is -expert -backs -former -trustees -cal I -to-test-for-I ead -i n -a I b e rta s -school -d ri n ki n g-wate r. htm I
4/25/2018 'We need to start acting on this': Expert backs former trustee's call to test for lead in Alberta's school drinking water I The Star
C 1-1
opyright owned or licensed by Toronto Star Newspapers Limited. All rights reserved.
Kublication or distribution of this content is expressly prohibited without the prior writterf
consent of Toronto Star Newspapers Limited and/or its licensors. To order copies of Toronto
Star articles, please go to: www.TorontoStarReprints.com
https://www.thestar.com/edmonton/20l8/O4/25/we-need-to-start-acting-on-this-expert-backs-former-trustees-call-to-test-for-lead-in-albertas-school-drinking-water.html
4/25/2018 `We need to start acting on this': Expert backs former trustee's call to test for lead in Alberta's school drinking water I The Star
https://www.thestar.com/ed monton/2018/O4/25/we-need-to-sta rt-acti ng-on-th is -expert -backs -former -trustees -cal I -to -test -for -lead -i n-albertas-school-dri nking-water. html