HomeMy WebLinkAboutQuebec spends $1.6M to replace word 'Amerindian' from history textbooks with proper Indigenous terms - National Post - 09/27/2018 - National Post - 09/27/20189/28/2018 Quebec spends $1.6M to replace word `Amerindian' from history textbooks with proper Indigenous terms I National Post
NATIONAL'*POST
NEWS m FULLCOMMENT , SPORTS 4 CULTURE w LIFE a MORE > DRIVING n CLASSIFIEDS - JOBS m SUBSCRIBE , FINAN(IALPOST m VIDEO
Quebec spends $1.6M to replace word
Wmerindian'f rom history textbooks
with proper Indigenous terms
W
A,rr7f notion, t'm C➢�2 'P,C t t7C' (R!if t' � , ., )f' f ,CfXn' f P,f' j iPf"r ,f"f
whic i roh t Arne°1nelian tends, to Whiny .. is totall fill w
an,d nwe ds to be currtxt.ed'
Ghislain Picard, chief of the Assembly of First Nations Quebec -Labrador 'C'r•cvor 11ag nlrilae t anucha n
Pr ss/Fr e
yiirF. CANADIAN PliFSS
MONTREAL — The Quebec government has just spent
STDHARTHA BANFRJFF
$1.6 million to replace the word "Amerindian" and modify
September 27, 2018
other Indigenous content in history textbooks that had
12:55 PM EDT
Last Updated
been introduced only two years earlier.
September 27, 2018
11:21 PM EDT
Amid controversy over the price tag, First Nations leaders
Filed under
say the changes were an essential gesture of respect.
Canadian Politics
Online Genealogy -
Free
I::anter a came, and 0LJ1'technoogy
vv01 do I he it V. c Ihairl 110W frrt(tY
https://nationalpost.com/news/politics/quebec-spends-1-6-million-editing-history-textbooks-to-use-proper-indigenous-terms 1/6
9/28/2018 Quebec spends $1.6M to replace word `Amerindian' from history textbooks with proper Indigenous terms I National Post
NATIONAL'*POST
NEWS m FULL(OMMENT , SPORTS 4 CULTURE w LIFE a MORE > DRIVING n CLASSIFIEDS - JOBS m SUBSCRIBE , FINAN(IALPOST m VIDEO
f "^a aeddit
TOP NEWS VIDEOS
He said "Autochtones" in French or "Indigenous peoples"
Watch Fourundecidl
Email
senators meet privately
in English are the accepted terms today. "Any notion that
before Kavanaugh vote
���
��1i° More
we would be `Indians of the Americas' —which is what
today: 'There's some
�� concerns'
Amerindian tends to imply — is totally false and needs to
RECOMMENDED
be corrected."
Watch .Aguide toth(
FOR YOU
The province authorized the contentious 2016 print run
U.S. Senate hearing with
Christine Blasey Ford ant
before the province's curriculum had been formally
Brett Kavanaugh
approved and is now stuck with the bill for reprinting the
textbooks in French and English.
Watch Read the the
full transcript of Donald
Marni Soupcoff: The
The books were for a Quebec history course introduced
Trump's UN speech
Kavanaugh -Ford
in 2016 for students in Grades 9 and 10. That course,
hearing just made
everything about this
drafted under the previous Parti Quebecois government,
worse
already had detractors. They said it reflects a rigid
Watch At least 25
nationalist ideology and diminishes the role of non -p°
killed, 60 injured after
disguised gunmen attack
francophones in Quebec history.
Iranian annual military
parade
Education Department spokesman Bryan St -Louis said in
an email that in addition to the references to Amerindians
SHARE YOUR FEEDBACK
A smart home is a less-
or Native Americans being replaced with terms such as
private home
We want to improve your reading experienc
"First Nations", "Inuit" and "Indigenous," other Indigenous
history content was modified.
Take our Go -second surnc;q
For example, images depicting Indigenous people in a
stereotypical way were changed, biographies of
Hundreds of Serbian 9 g
Indigenous Indi historical figures were added and more DAILY HEADLINE NEWS
weevi Is are being attention was paid to the Indigenous role in key historical
released in Banff Email
National Park to control events.
an invasive weed
St -Louis was unable to say how many books had to be By clicking "Submit", I consent to receiving the above
communication from Postmedia Network Inc. I understand
that I may unsubscribe from these communications at any
destroyed and reprinted. time.
Subtiait
I think were just coming up
with common terms that
would be acceptable to all
https://nationalpost.com/news/politics/quebec-spends-1-6-million-editing-history-textbooks-to-use-proper-indigenous-terms 2/6
9/28/2018 Quebec spends $1.6M to replace word `Amerindian' from history textbooks with proper Indigenous terms I National Post
NATIONAL'*POST
NEWS m FULL(OMMENT , SPORTS 4 (ULTURE w LIFE a MORE > DRIVING n CLASSIFIEDS - JOBS m SUBSCRIBE , FINAN(IALPOST m VIDEO
debate on semantics; it also allows for a much-needed
rectification of proper history instruction," the council said
in a statement. "We believe that mutual understanding
and establishing the facts are paramount in a context of
reconciliation."
Picard said terminology issues should not be taken
lightly, noting the francophone majority would not accept
being decribed by the outdated term "French-Canadian"
in official materials.
He acknowledged that language is constantly evolving,
even within Indigenous societies. He gave the example of
the word "band," which is increasingly being replaced by
"First Nation" to describe the governance system.
"Many communities still use that term (band), which is
really related to the Indian Act itself which has been
criticized left and right," Picard said. "But I think we're just
coming up with common terms that would be acceptable
to all."
History teacher Robert Green called the revisions a good
first step, noting the Truth and Reconciliation Commission
gave clear guidelines to the provinces for what should be
reflected in the high school courses.
Green, who teaches at Westmount High School and
heads a committee seeking changes to the history
curriculum, said other minority groups, including English-
speaking Quebecers, still receive short shrift.
"The current curriculum doesn't reflect the values of an
inclusive, democratic society," Green said. "It sends a
message that if you are not a member of the francophone
majority, you're a second-class citizen whose history
doesn't count or doesn't matter."
2Comments
Share,yourthoughts
LATEST POLITICS
Watch Chris Selley: From Ontario PCs,
common sense revolution on marijuana sal
Freeland vs. Lighthizer: Trump's public dig z
Canadian NAFTA negotiators underline
tensions
WT ,tch John Ivison: Tweaking Trump's
nose hasn't helped, but it's not why we don
have a NAFTA deal
MPs vote to revoke Aung San Suu I(yi's
honorary Canadian citizenship
https://nationalpost.com/news/politics/quebec-spends-1-6-million-editing-history-textbooks-to-use-proper-indigenous-terms 3/6
9/28/2018 Quebec spends $1.6M to replace word `Amerindian' from history textbooks with proper Indigenous terms I National Post
NATIONAL'*POST
NEWS m FULL(OMMENT , SPORTS 4 (ULTURE w LIFE a MORE > DRIVING n CLASSIFIEDS - JOBS m SUBSCRIBE , FINAN(IALPOST m VIDEO
becoming our Governor General
all the time, and Prince Harry has the
time
CANADIAN POLITICS
Wretch Chris Selley: From Ontario PCs, a common sense revolution on marijuana sales
Watch John Ivison: Tweaking Trump's nose hasn't helped, but it's not why we don't have a NAFTA deal
MPs vote to revoke Aung San Suu I<yi's honorary Canadian citizenship
Stripping ex -Nazi death squad member, 94, of Canadian citizenship 'reasonable,court rules
Watch 'Do the honourable thing': New Brunswick Tory leader Blaine Higgs calls on Premier Brian Gallant to resign
Watch Christie Blatchford: Why the case of Elizabeth Wettlaufer, the serial killer nurse, should outrage all Canadians
TOP STORIES
https://nationalpost.com/news/politics/quebec-spends-1-6-million-editing-history-textbooks-to-use-proper-indigenous-terms 4/6
9/28/2018 Quebec spends $1.6M to replace word `Amerindian' from history textbooks with proper Indigenous terms I National Post
NATIONAL'*POST
NEWS m FULLCOMMENT , SPORTS Q CULTURE w LIFE a MORE > DRIVING n CLASSIFIEDS - JOBS m SUBSCRIBE , FINANCIALPOST m VIDEO
Here's what happened
It starts with lobsters. You have to understand about the lobsters
Canada's first face
transplant
'It snapped into place perfectly, like a puzzle piece'
The CIA has declassified a bunch of jokes. Here are the best ones
A man was jailed 15 years for calling Joseph Stalin a fathead. One year for sedition, 14 years for revealing a state secret
THIS WEEK'S FLYERS
ef, ,, 1111111111111111111111111111111,
"rtd "Yfl
0
Hover" Emil° 114 I11yelP
D
�uNNnnnnnouuuuuuuuuuuuurl s uuuuuuuNNNNnnnnnouuuuuuuuuuuuuu
%M
� IN
a
IU MAM rfm 111MIN
ua
11 toveii%, iiip 114°°I11iii°
uuuuuNnnnnnouuuuuuuuuuuuuu uuuuuuuNNNNnnnnnouuuuuuuuuuuuuu
11 toveir Emil°, 114 I11yer
i I, ""?,ti o i l I` I SIH o,i I IF aceh,? ,t
1 Comment Sort by Top
Add a comment...
4IBruce Stanlleyy
1 hopeinthe name of accuracy they changed it to Siberian immigratts who were one
of the first here"
Like - Reply - 1 m
Farebook Cornrnents Hugh
tuaaaupppflNuuuuuouuuuuuuuuuuuuuiu texdl
�mn� 1 tllll i 11
m 4 I �n
k
�llvl.gig I�I��Y,su
arli
Itl.. nrn LT _ KU
11 toveir fair, III°°III
Pow re(
https://nationalpost.com/news/politics/quebec-spends-1-6-million-editing-history-textbooks-to-use-proper-indigenous-terms 5/6
9/28/2018 Quebec spends $1.6M to replace word 'Amerindian' from history textbooks with proper Indigenous terms I National Post
NATIONAL'*POST
NEWS - FULL(OMMENT - SPORTS - (ULTURE - LIFE - MORE - DRIVING - CLASSIFIEDS - JOBS - SUBSCRIBE - FINAKIALPOST - VIDEO
Cass"Ifieds
1011nomborling
C ell e b ratl I I q
(" Ilan sihods Mailketplace
Cni,eers
1yel-c"lly
lost a Classilleds ad
11 roach )Il �:Ck�)Iy
lrivac,/ orrin", Cupyiniflil
Adve irt'llsew'11 I i 1.1s
IartnIslhljps
Alopolinlinien1l "Io ice
solullons
Resomrnes
Cr)1111ml Works
Sa��es Directory My Account S�ay Coll
All i I l Js sul'-)scrlbc,�r SeF:�c,�Irvo 0
ell�lquei, 411)
coiflac[ Uls
https:llnationalpost.com/newsipolitics/quebec-spends-1-6-million-editing-history-textbooks-to-use-proper-indigenous-terms 6/6