HomeMy WebLinkAboutSmartphone refuseniks are a rare but happy breed - Globe & Mail - 12/23/2018 - Globe & Mail - 12/23/201812/24/2018
Smartphone refuseniks are a rare but happy breed - The Globe and Mail
Smartphone refuseniks are a rare but happy breed
In a country where most of us own smartphones but are ambivalent about digital
dependence, a few are deliberately logging off — and they say it's done wonders for
their imaginations and peace of mind
ELIZABETH RENZETTI ),
IP U.Ji IIS 11 11 S II I IF.11) 2 1110 lJ R S A G 0
https://www.thegIobeandmai1.com/business/technology/article-smartphone-refuseniks-are-a-rare-but-happy-breed/ 1/12
12/24/2018
Smartphone refuseniks are a rare but happy breed - The Globe and Mail
Then you notice someone in the office not scrolling or raging, but sitting quietly, perhaps
reading a magazine or staring into space. Poor wretch, you think. She's forgotten her phone
at home.
But what if she doesn't have a phone at all? It's hard to imagine, when three-quarters of
Canadians own smartphones (the figure rises to 94 per cent of 15- to 34 -year-olds.) But there
is indeed a rare species that shuns or severely limits smartphones and social media — let's call
them digital refuseniks. They are hidden among us, neither jobless nor friendless, and living
quite happily. Cut off from Uber, yet somehow thriving.
For example, Tony North does not live for his smartphone, because he's never had one. "I
just didn't want to get into the habit of distraction," he says simply, in an interview
conducted over landline from his home in Paris, Ont. The high-school teacher spends about
20 minutes a day on his one social -media platform, Facebook, which he uses to keep in
touch with family back home in Australia. In fact, you could blame Australia for Mr. North's
desire to be digitally unleashed: He remembers leaving home to travel overseas, and the
wonderful feeling of being uncontactable that came with it. "It was such a feeling of freedom,
and I guess I wanted to keep a bit of that."
https://www.theglobeandmail.com/business/technology/article-smartphone-refuseniks-are-a-rare-but-happy-breed/ 2/12
12/24/2018
Smartphone refuseniks are a rare but happy breed - The Globe and Mail
Nh e Worths' oimlly Ihoinne computer 6s a Ilallptolpu used imostlly to stay iiia touch Mth fairnRy iiia AustirKalliia.
TIIImGTIiX ImGGFzf::.:jf'IilF.: G11 01131F..: AICVID MAIIll
IMehssa Worth owns the onlly celllllplh one iin the I1 --muse, w1hk1h slhe uses immostIly for work."T"he clhddireim cairn use sor ne
apris on Saturday lnoirin ngs,
rII1MG.fIIIY lMCIGGIRIE.:./FIIIIfi GIL..UlaE..: AIC'sID ICMAIIll
https://www.theglobeandmail.com/business/technology/article-smartphone-refuseniks-are-a-rare-but-happy-breed/ 3/12
12/24/2018 Smartphone refuseniks are a rare but happy breed - The Globe and Mail
Illi irlpeir Worth treads iiirn her iroorrn. 11leir Bigg tall irefuseimiill< Fath ir„ a drarna teadher, finds imoire hirne for inovells and
irmoirnrneints of ire llechoirn wWhou t a .sirinartlphar ne..
r II IC's G.f IL..I Y IM O f:1 R E.: / f IL..I 11th G IL.. G IIS 11th A Int IIS lid A II IL..
As a teacher of English and drama, Mr. North, 53, is worried about the consequences of
teenagers' near -constant devotion to their online lives (his own two children, 12 and 13 years
old, do not have phones). In drama class, he makes his students put away their phones and
engage in face-to-face exercises: "I'm basically forcing them to interact," he says. "When I ask
for evaluations at the end of the semester, it's one of the things they most seem to
appreciate."
And yes, before you ask, there are inconveniences, too. Because he has no smartphone, if he
wants to take his students on a field trip, he has to partner with a teacher who has one (and
they all do) because the group must be reachable. But as compensation, he reads many
novels and enjoys quiet moments of reflection and watching the world go by.
Talk to digital refuseniks and you'll hear some variation on this: They love the quiet
wandering of their own imaginations. "Drift, wait, obey," was Rudyard Kipling's recipe for
inspiration, a sentiment that is almost unimaginable today, when our minds are constantly
being filled with micro -nuggets of unrelated information.
https://www.theglobeandmail.com/business/technology/article-smartphone-refuseniks-are-a-rare-but-happy-breed/ 4/12
12/24/2018 Smartphone refuseniks are a rare but happy breed - The Globe and Mail
Bethany IMairdh rldes the subway Ih oirrne firoirrn York Uirniveirslity, whneire she its In Iheir first year studying IF=ire nchn
duuca fllorn. She Iles a sirnairt1p1h ohne, but uses iii as Ilii Ile as possHle..
rIIIMO .fIIIXIMoORIE.: F11 HE.: GIIGIli$r::i AND ICMAIIII
'I DIDN'T WANT TO BE THAT PERSON'
For Bethany March, who severely restricts her digital use, contentment lies in people -
watching. "I was on the streetcar for 40 minutes yesterday," the 18 -year-old university
student says, "and I did nothing. Everyone else was on their phones, but I just looked out the
window."
Ms. March, who's in her first year of studying French education at York University,
reluctantly gave in and bought a smartphone when she was 16. All the information for her
school clubs was on Facebook, so she downloaded the app, and it's still the only one she has.
She uses her phone sparingly to call and text. And yes, her peers think it's strange that she
doesn't really use social media; but then she wonders about them, too.
"I saw the way that people got so invested, not just in their phones, but in social media, and I
didn't want to be that person," she says. "So many times people would be zeroed in on their
phones. It was just rude, to be honest. I'd think, `I'm here with you, talk to me."'
https://www.theglobeandmail.com/business/technology/article-smartphone-refuseniks-are-a-rare-but-happy-breed/ 5/12
12/24/2018 Smartphone refuseniks are a rare but happy breed - The Globe and Mail
She uses her sinnartlphoine .spa riiirnglly.
rIIIC'so.fIL..IYIMoORE.:/I1IL..IE.: G IL..oIISE:.: AND lidAIIIL..
It's clear many people feel ambivalent about digital dependence. While some speak longingly
of shedding their shackles, few ever completely do it — and in a 2016 Statscan survey, 60 per
cent of Canadians said technology improved their lives. Much of people's professional and
personal lives relies on social -media connections, and the convenience of online experiences,
creating almost a disembodied self. The tension exists between that convenience and sense
of fellowship and the ever -mounting worries about what technology dependency does to
physical and mental health. Canadians between the ages of 18 and 34 spend nearly five
hours a day online, according to a 2017 survey from Media Technology Monitor. On average,
Canadians spent 24.5 hours online per week in 2016, up two hours per week from the year
before. And that is almost certainly an underestimation. when all flickers and glances and
https://www.theglobeandmail.com/business/technology/article-smartphone-refuseniks-are-a-rare-but-happy-breed/ 6/12
12/24/2018 Smartphone refuseniks are a rare but happy breed - The Globe and Mail
W i° Itl�"l' r C R:Al�k
Zuckerberg Initiative, a foundation created by Priscilla Chan and her husband, Facebook
founder Mark Zuckerberg: "I am convinced the devil lives in our phones and is wreaking
havoc on our children."
That's a fear shared by many parents, and even some of their kids. Sophie Bezanson is 1S,
and she's glad that her parents have not bought her a phone. Interestingly, her parents made
the decision to give her more freedom and independence to be herself, without supervision.
She is the only one of her friends who doesn't have a phone or use social media. When they
wait for the school bus in New Minas, N.S., the other students are on their phones. Sophie
gets to daydream, or read, or think about the day ahead.
There are moments when the Grade 10 student does feel a fleeting fear of missing out, as the
latest meme or joke goes over her head: "Social media is how my generation communicates.
If I meet someone, they'll say, `Just add me on Instagram.' And I have to tell them that I only
have e-mail, which sounds like a thing of the past. Sometimes I wish I could communicate
faster with people."
Like all refuseniks, Sophie makes delicate calibrations all the time: What are the costs, and
what are the benefits, of sitting out the dance when everyone else is on the floor? She's been
discussing with her parents the possibility of joining Instagram, and the other night she was
paging through the social -media platform famous for its aspirational content. She came
across a friend's feed, and found something she had not expected: "It was her showing off
her body, and that really surprised me. I think a lot of people do that, they try to shape their
lives in a perfect way. It isn't very realistic, but I see it a lot."
https://www.theglobeandmail.com/business/technology/article-smartphone-refuseniks-are-a-rare-but-happy-breed/ 7/12
12/24/2018 Smartphone refuseniks are a rare but happy breed - The Globe and Mail
Your srnartphone is making,you stupid, antisocial and unhealthy, So why can't you brut it down? Eric Andrew -Gee
loons at the grooming body of scientific evidence that digital distraction is damaging our minds, lead more here.
'THEY LOVE TO HATE IT'
The effort of social -media performance can be draining, as anyone who spends a lot of time
online will know. After a certain amount of time, the return on investment may seem
increasingly small, and the performance itself becomes drudgery. Then the phoneless
become less objects of pity, and more of envy.
https://www.theglobeandmail.com/business/technology/article-smartphone-refuseniks-are-a-rare-but-happy-breed/ 8/12
12/24/2018 Smartphone refuseniks are a rare but happy breed - The Globe and Mail
W i° Itl�"l' r C R:Al�k
However, the 71 -year-old Vancouverite has the phone only because his cycling group
requires it, and he has "only ever used it to make sure it works." Like Mr. North, he likes the
freedom of being disconnected, especially when he is travelling. It means he is really
experiencing a new location, "rather than trying to be in two places at once."
He gets a particular response from digitally connected people, which is perhaps not too
strange when you think about it: jealousy. "Whenever I tell people I don't have a phone, they
say, `Oh, that's so great. I wish I didn't have to have one.' It's odd that people look at it that
way, as if the phone itself is something alive. They love to hate it."
They may not always know the latest score and they may be late discovering what Kanye
West's politics are, but that's one thing digital refuseniks never have to worry about: Who is
the servant in their digital relationship, and who is the master.
https://www.theglobeandmail.com/business/technology/article-smartphone-refuseniks-are-a-rare-but-happy-breed/ 9/12
12/24/2018
Smartphone refuseniks are a rare but happy breed - The Globe and Mail
DIGITAL DISTRACTIONS: MORE READING FROM THE GLOBE AND MAIL
Can we ever kick our smartphone addiction? Jim Balsillie and Norman Doidge discuss
The next battleground for sex education: safe sexting
Tackling tech: How some Ontario teachers are attempting to limit students' cellphone
use
IF: G IL.. IL..0 MDA IF.: IL.. II Z A B If:. IL..II R 1F:. IN z If:::..f ..f II ON ..r..W II ..r..r If::: II?
1.. 11 Z IR IF N Z IFT T II
l?l:l,0i:fir AIN I::::Rf 0l? If:.D11.F0R111A11 O'0 f.DlF.: 0If: CG IN11)UC.f
cap im inn ii::: ivr.s
https://www.theglobeandmail.com/business/technology/article-smartphone-refuseniks-are-a-rare-but-happy-breed/ 10/12
12/24/2018 Smartphone refuseniks are a rare but happy breed - The Globe and Mail
W i° / l' r t I,AI
„ ........... e 7 U ,LOCKS NOW t5eTore i ne %ipportunity Kuns vut
I.....iberty if lhirough Wealth
Read our OB plan case study on allocating to global real estate
Invesco Canada
da
Stop stressing over stocks - get the 6 stocks to buy and hold forever.
Wealthy lRet:iirer neirnt
12 Months. 1 Life -Altering ROI. The Master of Finance from Schulich.
sc;hulliich Schooll of Iliusiirness
L" ,:oI!Lel (I IES q!,[I��I�rt.11'I (°�� TM;���IL�hLII�L`.R Ll /S,C( P,a1,1CY 1)15 C 1,AII',LR'z
13 U 5 111,1114 S Tilt 1'S
https://www.theglobeandmail.com/business/technology/article-smartphone-refuseniks-are-a-rare-but-happy-breed/ 11/12
12/24/2018 Smartphone refuseniks are a rare but happy breed - The Globe and Mail
Dowin1load oin Ohe G1 IF IIIOIN
App Staire > Go'og�le 1:::'by
.....................................................................................................................
1, 1101
f v n
https://www.theglobeandmail.com/business/technology/article-smartphone-refuseniks-are-a-rare-but-happy-breed/ 12/12